Use of Solid Corrugated Particles
to Enhance Powder
Aerosol Performance
Nora Y. K. Chew
1
and Hak-Kim Chan
1,2
Received April 26, 2001; August 3, 2001
Purpose. To study the dispersion performance of non-porous corru-
gated particles, with a focus on the effect of particle surface morphol-
ogy on aerosolization of bovine serum albumin (BSA) powders.
Methods. The solid-state characteristics of the spray-dried BSA pow-
ders, one consisting of smooth spherical particles and another corru-
gated particles, were characterized by laser diffraction, X-ray powder
diffraction, scanning electron microscopy, confocal microscopy, ther-
mogravimetric analysis, surface area analyzer, and buoyancy method.
The powders were dispersed using the Rotahaler and the Dinki-
haler coupled to a four-stage liquid impinger operating at 30 to 120
L/min. Fine particle fraction (FPF) was expressed as the wt. % of
BSA particles of size 5 m collected from the liquid impinger.
Results. Apart from the morphology and morphology-related prop-
erties (specific surface area, envelope density), the corrugated par-
ticles and spherical particles of BSA had very similar solid-state char-
acteristics (particle size distribution, water content, true density,
amorphous nature). Using the Dinkihaler, the FPFs of the corru-
gated particles were 10–20 wt. % higher than those of the smooth
particles. Similar FPF differences were found for the powders dis-
persed by the Rotahaler, but the relative changes were larger. In
addition, the differences were inversely proportional to the air flows
(17.3% at 30 L/min, 25.2% at 60 L/min, 13.8% at 90, 8.5% at 120
L/min). Depending on the inhaler, capsule and device retention and
impaction loss at the impinger throat were lower for the corrugated
particles.
Conclusions. Enhanced aerosol performance of powders can be ob-
tained by surface modification of the particles. The surface asperities
of the corrugated particles could lower the true area of contact be-
tween the particles, and thus reduce the powder cohesiveness. A
distinct advantage of using corrugated particles is that the inhaler
choice and air flow become less critical for these particles.
KEY WORDS: protein; dry powder aerosol; spherical; corrugated;
spray drying.
INTRODUCTION
Dry powders are increasingly used for the aerosol deliv-
ery of small molecule drugs and therapeutic proteins to the
lung (1–17). The generation of dry powder aerosols is influ-
enced by many factors, including both the inhaler device and
the particle characteristics (1). It has been demonstrated that
particle morphology could be manipulated by the formulation
and the method of preparation (2–5). Spray drying of com-
pounds of different compositions (3,5–7) resulted in a change
of particle morphology, which is potentially of importance in
the development of therapeutic powder aerosol formulations.
To date, investigators have observed that large porous
particles (∼10–20 m, specific surface area ∼50–100 m
2
/g) im-
proved the amount of respirable particles both in vitro (5,6,8)
and in vivo (9,10,18). Despite the large physical size, these
porous particles showed excellent aerosol performance. This
has been attributed to the low particle density (i.e., high po-
rosity or voids), which gives rise to small aerodynamic size.
On the other hand, French and co-workers found that the
inclusion of protein rhG-CSF with mannitol resulted in a less
dense powder with surface indentations leading to an increase
in the surface area of the powder. The performance of the
highly indented mannitol-rhG-CSF particles was better than
the mannitol particles alone (19). The improvement was at-
tributed to smaller interparticulate cohesive forces resulting
from the surface indentation and reduced bulk density. How-
ever, the presence of protein in the mannitol particles may
also attribute to the weaker cohesion through reducing the
Hamaker constant (hence reduced van der Waals force).
In contrast to those porous particles, solid, non-porous
corrugated particles containing no additives were obtained in
the present study. Our aim was to compare the dispersion
behavior of the corrugated particles with smooth, spherical
particles of similar physical properties. The focus was on the
effect of surface morphology on the dispersion of dry powders
as aerosols, using bovine serum albumin (BSA) as a model
compound. Studies were conducted at various air flows using
two inhalers of different dispersion efficiencies.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Powder Preparation
The powders were obtained by spray drying using a Bu-
chi 191 spray dryer (Flawil, Switzerland). The feed solution
containing BSA (Fraction V, minimum 98%, lot 97HO984,
Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO) dissolved in deionized
water was sprayed at following conditions: aspiration rate 57.6
m
3
/h, feed rate 1.4 mL/min, inlet and outlet air temperatures
45 and 36°C, respectively, and atomizing air pressure 400 and
600 kPa for the corrugated and smooth spherical particles,
respectively.
Solid-State Characterization
Particle Morphology
Powder samples were mounted onto metal sample plates
and coated with platinum (∼3 nm thick). The samples were
then examined under a Jeol JSM 6000F scanning electron
microscope (Tokyo, Japan), operating at 2–3 kV.
Particle Interior Structure
Powder (approximately 1–2 mg) was fixed on a glass slide
using glutaraldehyde (0.1 v/v%, Sigma Chemical Co., St.
Louis, Missouri), dried overnight, and viewed under a confo-
cal microscope (Bio-Rad Radiance Plus scanning system,
Hertfordshire, UK). Continuous sectioning along the z-axis of
the specimen via the confocal microscope allowed the detec-
tion of void(s) in the particle (20).
1
Faculty of Pharmacy, A15, University of Sydney, NSW 2006 Aus-
tralia.
2
To whom correspondence should be addressed. (e-mail: kimc@
pharm.usyd.edu.au)
Pharmaceutical Research, Vol. 18, No. 11, November 2001 (© 2001) Research Paper
1570 0724-8741/01/1100-1570$19.50/0 © 2001 Plenum Publishing Corporation