Curr. Med. Chem. - Anti-Cancer Agents, 2003, 3, 133-138 133
1568-0118/03 $41.00+.00 © 2003 Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
Second Generation Taxanes: from the Natural Framework to the
Challenge of Drug Resistance
Cristiano Ferlini
1
, Iwao Ojima
3
, Mariagrazia Distefano
1
, Daniela Gallo
1
, Antonella Riva
2
, Paolo
Morazzoni
2
, Ezio Bombardelli
2
, Salvatore Mancuso
1
, and Giovanni Scambia
1,
*
1
Laboratory of Antineoplastic Pharmacology, Dept. Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Università Cattolica Sacro Cuore,
Rome, Italy,
2
Indena S.p.A., Milan, Italy and
3
Department of Chemistry at SUNY Stony Brook, Stony Brook, NY, USA
Abstract: Taxanes represent the most important class of antitumor agents introduced in cancer therapy in the last decade.
The first member of the family was paclitaxel, firstly isolated from Taxus Brevifolia and found active as antitumor agent
at the end of 60's. In the mid of 90's, a semi-synthetic taxane derived from 10-deacetylbaccatin III was introduced and
thereafter named as docetaxel. Taxanes act by inhibiting microtubule dynamics, thereby inducing the arrest in M phase
and the consequent activation of the apoptotic program. Since target of taxanes is not directly the genome, they are
effective alone or in combination with DNA-damaging drugs in tumors not responding to conventional
chemotherapeutics, such as advanced breast and non small cell lung cancer. In this review we will cover the aspects of
clinical applications of the currently used taxanes as well as the clinical problems related to their use. Taking into
consideration such problems, new taxanes have been developed in order to extend the spectrum of taxane-sensitive tumors
and several of them are currently undergoing clinical trials. Among these agents, a newly developed taxane (BAY 59-
8862) appears particularly interesting for the fact that it shows excellent oral bioavailability and activity in tumors with
inherent resistance to paclitaxel.
HISTORY AND PREHISTORY OF TAXANES
Taxanes are natural compounds isolated from American
(Taxus brevifolia), Canadian ( Taxus canadiensis), Chinese
(Taxus mairei, T. yunnaensis, T. chinensis), Himalayan
(Taxus wallichiana) and European (Taxus baccata) yews.
The beginning taxane use in folk remedies is lost in the mists
of time. However, the toxic properties of the foliage, seeds
and bright red fruits (called arils) obtained from Taxus
species were known from prehistory and the tree was
considered holy for the ancient Celtic, Greek and Roman
cultures. The religious significance attributed to Taxus may
have occurred because this tree is symbolic of eternal life
due to its evergreenness, exceptional longevity and the
wood’s resistance to decay. Greeks consecrated yew to
Hecate, the guardian of the Underworld, while Celtics
planted Taxus baccata in their holiest shrines [1]. These
practices were preserved after the conversion to Christianity,
perhaps to further legitimise the new religion. Still now, it is
possible to find the old European yews near the old churches
in England and Ireland.
Despite the relevance that yews had in the European
tradition, the modern re-discovery of taxanes occurred in US
during the 60’s. A natural product screening conducted by
the U.S. National Cancer Institute (NCI) in conjunction with
the U.S. Department of Agriculture identified extracts of the
bark of Taxus Brevifolia that were highly cytotoxic and
possessed antitumour activity against a panel of rodent
tumors in mice and rats. Wani, and cooworkers isolated the
*Address correspondence to this author at the Department of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology, Università Cattolica Sacro Cuore, 00168, Rome- Italy;
Tel./Fax: 06-35508736; E-mail: giovanni.scambia@libero.it
active compound they called ‘Taxol’ from the bark of Taxus
brevifolia and found it highly active against a panel of rodent
tumors in mice [2]. The chemical name was subsequently
changed to “paclitaxel” when Bristol-Myers registered
TAXOL
as a brand name worldwide. Interest in this
compound waned for nearly a decade until Susan Horwitz
and her coworkers discovered that paclitaxel acts as a spindle
poison and blocks cell cycle at M phase by inhibiting tubulin
depolymerisation [3]. After such findings, the NCI began
conducting phase I clinical trials in 1983 and, later, phase II
clinical trials against several cancers [4-6]. To further
develop this drug (still called taxol), the NCI offered
exclusive rights to taxol available to the highest bidder upon
consideration of public benefit. This offer was allowed
through a recently enacted law in the U.S. Congress (the
Hatch-Waxman Act), which provided an avenue by which
discoveries in the public domain could become exclusive
within the U.S. and commercially valuable if the public
would benefit. Four U.S. pharmaceutical companies
submitted Cooperative Research and Development
Applications (CRADAs) and Bristol-Myers was awarded
exclusive rights to market taxol for five years from the New
Drug Application (NDA) approval date. After the excellent
results obtained in advanced ovary carcinoma at Johns
Hopkins Oncology Center, the Federal Drug Administration
(FDA) in the U.S. approved the use of TAXOL
in 1992 for
the treatment of advanced ovary cancer.
The challenge of improving the natural framework of
paclitaxel started even before that paclitaxel had finished
clinical trials. In the second half of 80’s, researchers at the
Rhone Poulenc laboratories developed ‘Taxotére’ (its
chemical name is ‘docetaxel’) from the naturally occurring
diterpene 10-deacetylbaccatin III, obtained from Taxus