990 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON PLASMA SCIENCE, VOL. 40, NO. 4, APRIL 2012
Nuclear Radiation-Induced Atmospheric Air
Breakdown in a Spark Gap
Shaolin Liao, Nachappa Gopalsami, Senior Member, IEEE, Eugene R. Koehl, Thomas W. Elmer, II, Member, IEEE,
Alexander Heifetz, Hual-Te Chien, and Apostolos C. Raptis, Life Member, IEEE
Abstract—We have investigated the effect of pre-ionization by a
radioactive
137
Cs γ -ray source on the atmospheric air breakdown
conditions in a high-voltage spark gap. A standoff millimeter-wave
(mmW) system was used to monitor the breakdown properties. A
decrease in breakdown threshold was observed with an increase of
radiation dose. We attribute this to a space charge-controlled elec-
tron diffusion process in a cloud of radiation-induced ion species of
both polarities. The space charge-dependent diffusion coefficient
was determined from the measurement data. In addition, we found
that the breakdown process shows random spikes with Poisson–
like statistical feature. These findings portend the feasibility of
remote detection of nuclear radiation using high-power mmWs.
Index Terms—Air breakdown, breakdown voltage, millimeter
wave (mmW), nuclear radiation, spark gap.
I. I NTRODUCTION
A
TMOSPHERIC AIR breakdown has been of great interest
in plasma physics [1], and its potential application to
remote detection of nuclear radiation-induced ionized air has
been explored recently [2]. Although the spark gap breakdown
has been known [3] for plasma generation, the physics of
breakdown parameters is not well understood in the presence
of nuclear radiation, particularly at atmospheric pressure. In this
paper, we present an analysis of the nuclear radiation-induced
air breakdown process in a dc spark gap and its detection with
a standoff millimeter-wave (mmW) system. The purpose of
our investigation is twofold: 1) demonstrate feasibility of high-
power mmW remote detection of nuclear radiation-induced
ionized air from its equivalent dc air breakdown investigation
and 2) shed light on the fundamental physics governing the
nuclear radiation-induced air breakdown process.
II. THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
A. DC Spark Gap and High-Power Microwave Breakdown
dc spark gap breakdown can be categorized into two types
[4]: the Townsend process at low pressure (p)—spark gap
separation (d) product, i.e., the pd value; and the streamer
Manuscript received October 25, 2011; revised January 17, 2012; accepted
January 29, 2012. Date of publication March 2, 2012; date of current version
April 11, 2012. This work was supported by the Defense Threat Reduc-
tion Agency under the U.S. Department of Energy Contract No. DE-AC02-
06CH11357.
The authors are with the Nuclear Engineering Division, Argonne National
Laboratory, Argonne, IL 60439 USA (e-mail: sliao@anl.gov; goplasami@anl.
gov; dick.koehl@anl.gov; elmer@anl.gov; aheifetz@anl.gov; htchien@anl.
gov; raptis@anl.gov).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPS.2012.2187343
process at high pd value. The Townsend type is an electron
avalanche process that involves both primary ionized electrons
in the air and the secondary electrons emitted at the cathode due
to impact of the positive ions [5], [6]. The breakdown voltage
can be obtained by solving the generalized Townsend equation
[7]. A streamer is a filament-like structure due to strong electric
field around the rapidly advancing and highly concentrated
avalanche front [8], [9].
The high-power microwave air breakdown can be explained
in terms of the effective electric field strength, i.e., E
eff
=
E
rms
/
1+(ω/ν
c
)
2
, where E
rms
is the root-mean-square
electric field and ω and ν
c
are the electromagnetic circular fre-
quency and electron collision frequency in the air, respectively.
High-power microwave experiments have also been studied in
various frequency bands and resonant cavities [10].
In both cases, breakdown electric field is obtained when the
electric field-dependent ionization rate ν
i
equals the attachment
loss rate ν
a
plus the diffusion loss rate ν
d
,
ν
i
(E
b
)= ν
a
(E
b
)+ ν
d
(E
b
) ∼ ν
a
(E
b
) -
D
Λ
2
eff
(1)
where E
b
is the breakdown dc or effective electric field strength
and D and Λ
eff
are the diffusion coefficient and effective
diffusion length, respectively. When ν
i
≪ ν
d
, (1) gives,
D ∼ ν
i
(E
b
)Λ
2
eff
. (2)
B. Preionization and Afterglow Effect
Microwave breakdown under various background ionization
concentrations ranging from 10
6
- 10
9
cm
-3
has been tested
[11] with a microwave cavity using Neon gas at pressures up
to 100 torr. It has been found that the breakdown field strength
could be reduced by more than 10% in the presence of pre-
ionization. The authors related such remarkable observation to
the transition from the free electron diffusion to the ambipolar
diffusion, which means the diffusion coefficient is also a func-
tion of ion density n
i
, D(n
i
); however, its detailed form has
not been obtained. The laser pre-ionization effect for an atmo-
spheric spark gap based on resonance enhanced multi-photon
ionization mechanism has also been investigated recently [12],
where a reduction of breakdown voltage up to 50% has been
achieved. However, the laser induced pre-ionization is along the
path of the laser instead of the whole space in the spark gap.
The afterglow in both dc spark gap and microwave air break-
down has a similar transition from space charge-controlled
0093-3813/$31.00 © 2012 IEEE