PHYSICAL REVIEW C 89, 034614 (2014)
Importance of nonlinearity in the NN potential
B. B. Sahu,
1 , *
S. K. Singh,
2
M. Bhuyan,
2
S. K. Biswal,
2
and S. K. Patra
2
1
Department of Physics, School of Applied Sciences, Kalinga Institute of Industrial Technology (KIIT) University, Bhubaneswar 751024, India
2
Institute of Physics, Sachivalaya Marg, Bhubaneswar 751005, India
(Received 18 November 2013; revised manuscript received 10 February 2014; published 17 March 2014)
A simple form of nonlinear self-coupling of the scalar meson field is introduced and suggests a new nucleon-
nucleon (NN ) potential in relativistic mean field theory (RMFT) analogous to the M3Y interaction. We investigate
the ability of RMFT to reproduce nuclear ground state properties and the surface phenomena like proton radioac-
tivity simultaneously with the proposed NN interaction. The results obtained agree reasonably well with the
widely used M3Y NN interactions and the experimental data in this first application of nucleon-nucleon potential.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevC.89.034614 PACS number(s): 21.30.Fe, 13.75.Cs, 21.10.−k, 21.65.−f
I. INTRODUCTION
In the nucleonic regime nuclei behave as sets of interacting
nucleons. In order to go beyond some basic nuclear models
which provide a global description of the system one has
to include in the picture the elementary interaction between
nucleons. One can then explore how the average potential
well, in which nucleons evolve, can be built up from this
elementary stone and thus gain a more microscopic picture of
nuclei as constructed from nucleons. Early field theoretical ap-
proaches [1] in the 1950s were generally unsuccessful. These
eventually gave way to more phenomenological treatments [2]
which provided a pragmatic way to describe the abundant NN
scattering and bound state (deuteron) data. In the beginning
of the 1970s many theoretical models emerged which were
more successful than the earlier attempts. These were based
on one-pion exchange (OPE), heavy meson exchange, and
multimeson exchange plus short-range phenomenology [3–6].
A key idea on which much theoretical machinery is founded
is the concept of the nuclear mean field, which basically relies
on the fact that nucleons move quasi-independently from one
another inside a nucleus. Although the mean field underlies
many of our discussions, one should not forget the elementary
nucleon-nucleon interaction from which it is built. But it is
not our aim to discuss here all the works which have been
devoted to the NN interaction. We thus only recall the shape
of the interaction with a few gross properties. We content
ourselves with noting that the dominant part of the interaction
is central and is strongly repulsive at short range (0.4 fm,
hard core) and attractive at intermediate range (∼1–1.2 fm).
This dominant repulsive and attractive shape of the interaction
is the typical widely used well known M3Y NN interaction [7].
The NN interaction cannot yet be derived from first principle
(QCD). So the existing potentials are thus, at least partly,
phenomenological and contain a possible large number of
parameters and are fitted to deuteron properties and available
phase shifts. This fitting procedure does not necessarily ensure
a proper reproduction of many-body properties, so for the first
time we try to give an NN interaction analogous to the M3Y
form derived from the relativistic-mean-field (RMF) theory
*
bbsnou@gmail.com
which leads to an overall agreement with the ground state bulk
properties, compressibility, and some radioactive properties of
proton drip-line nuclei and a superheavy region.
A. Importance of nonlinearity
It is to be noted that in our recently published paper [8] an
attempt has been made to simulate the M3Y NN interaction
from a simple Lagrangian [9,10]. However, the value of
compressibility obtained is quite large, about 550 MeV
(though it is difficult to determine empirically, in fact it is
about 210 ± 30 MeV [11]). Later on its application to finite
nuclei [12] shows that the results also deviate far from the
experiment. To overcome the above mentioned difficulties
we take the Lagrangian of Boguta and Bodmer [13] who have
for the first time included the cubic and quartic terms in the
scalar field. Actually they [13] studied the empirical properties
of nuclear matter and finite nuclei without abnormal solution
involving the nonlinear terms in the original linear σ -ω model
of Miller and Green [9] in 1977. It is well understood that
the binding energy (BE), charge radius, and deformation
parameter (β
2
) of finite nuclei from
20
Ne to
238
U is studied
thoroughly and some of them are presented in Fig. 1.
It is clearly seen from the the figure that the linear model,
where nonlinear self-couplings of the mesons are switched off,
gives a modest fit. The experimental data can be reproduced
with an average error of above 20% for the energies, 0.7%
for the radii, and above 50% for the β
2
parameter. The
full parametrization, including the nonlinearities, allows an
excellent fit. It reproduces the experimental data with an
average error of below 0.3% for energies, 0.3% for the radii,
and comparatively less error in the β
2
parameter. This proves
that a relativistic treatment of the nucleus with an explicit
nonlinear mesonic degree of freedom is fully capable of repro-
ducing the bulk properties of finite nuclei. The simultaneous
explanation of surface phenomena like proton radioactivity is
quite impressive over the linear one, which will be discussed
later. Also the properties of infinite nuclear matter such as
radius and mass of the neutron star cannot be produced within
the experimental range with the linear Walecka model. Again
this nonlinearity generates an analogous effect of the three
body interaction due to its off-shell meson couplings, which
is essential for the saturation properties [14,15]. We present
0556-2813/2014/89(3)/034614(8) 034614-1 ©2014 American Physical Society