Received: 19 November, 2008. Accepted: 21 February, 2009.
Original Research Paper
International Journal of Plant Breeding ©2009 Global Science Books
Immature Embryo Culture for Early Screening
of Imidazolinone Resistance in Sunflower
Gabriela Breccia
1,2
• Tatiana Vega
1,2
• Graciela Nestares
1*
• María Laura Mayor
1
•
Roxana Zorzoli
1,3
• Liliana Picardi
1,3
1
Cátedra de Genética, Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Campo Experimental “J. F. Villarino”, C.C. 14, S2125ZAA Zavalla, Argentina
2
Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Tecnológicas (CONICET), Argentina
3
Consejo de Investigaciones de la Universidad Nacional de Rosario (CIUNR), Argentina
Corresponding author: * gnestare@unr.edu.ar
ABSTRACT
The development of imidazolinone-resistant sunflower cultivars represents a great advantage in controlling weeds. This type of herbicide
resistance can only be achieved with homozygosis of two resistant genes; hence breeding for this trait is time-consuming. The objectives
of this study were to develop plantlets from immature sunflower embryos to evaluate imazethapyr resistance. Three methods were used,
an in vitro technique and two non-sterile techniques (dish and pot assays). Three genotypes differing in imidazolinone resistance were
evaluated for germination and plantlet developmental variables. Immature embryos successfully germinated in the in vitro culture and the
pot germination techniques having similar efficiency. Given the simplicity of the pot assay, plantlets from pot germination were used for
screening herbicide resistance at four different doses: 2.5, 5, 7.5 and 10 μM. Susceptible plants showed chlorosis and arrested growth,
mainly when exposed to 7.5 and 10 μM of imazethapyr. Surviving plants were transferred to pots and placed in a greenhouse and
successfully completed their lifecycle. The techniques described herein would allow selecting sunflower inbreds for imidazolinone
resistance when shortening breeding cycle.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Keywords: Helianthus annuus L., herbicide resistance, in vitro culture, pot germination
Abbreviation: ALS, acetolactate synthase
INTRODUCTION
Weed competition causes substantial yield loss in sunflower
(Helianthus annuus L.). Competition experiments showed
that weeded conditions produced a 20 to 53% loss in yield
compared to weed-free conditions (Blamey and Zollinger
1997). Genes for resistance to acetolactate synthase (ALS)-
inhibiting herbicides in sunflower have been introgressed
from resistant wild populations (ANN-PUR and ANN-
KAN) into elite inbred lines for the purpose of developing
herbicide resistant cultivars and hybrids (Al-Khatib et al.
1998; Miller and Al-Khatib 2002).
Bruniard and Miller (2001) proposed a digenic model
for the inheritance of imidazolinone resistance. In this model,
a major gene (Imr
1
) has a semidominant type of gene action
and a second gene (Imr
2
) acts as modifier when the major
gene is present. According to these authors, complete resis-
tance in sunflower can only be achieved with homozygosity
of both resistant genes (Imr
1
Imr
1
Imr
2
Imr
2
) in an inbred line
or hybrid.
The development of resistant elite inbred lines to further
inclusion in hybrid programs involves introgression of the
resistance genes into elite germplasm by backcrossing.
Besides being a time-consuming process, it also implies one
or more generations of self pollination and progeny testing
to correctly classify and select the resistant phenotypes
(Bruniard and Miller 2001). Operationally, identification of
imidazolinone resistant genotypes involves applying herbi-
cide to plants grown in the field or greenhouse, being a time-
consuming and costly task. Initially, a laboratory technique
that allows early screening resistant genotypes would be a
useful tool to help reducing time and resources when breed-
ing for imidazolinone resistance.
Embryo culture is one of the earliest in vitro culture me-
thodologies applied to practical problems and has proven of
greatest value to breeders (Bridgen 1994). Its major applica-
tion in sunflower plant breeding has been for overcoming
incompatibility in interspecific crosses (Chandler and Beard
1983; Denat et al. 1991; Kräuter et al. 1991; Sukno et al.
1999). Immature embryo culture has also been a technique
extensively used for shortening the breeding cycle in this
species, allowing four to five generations per year (Plotni-
kov 1983; Alissa et al. 1986; Azpiroz et al. 1987; Jambhul-
kar 1995). In contrast, non-sterile germination techniques
represent a simpler and cheaper alternative to in vitro
culture of immature sunflower embryos (Paul and Barthou
1994; Torresán et al. 1996).
Culture of immature embryos for rapid fixation of
inbred lines will be of particular interest only if selection
can be achieved at the same time. Given that breeding for
imidazolinone resistance requires a considerable amount of
time and resources, culture of immature embryos followed
by selection of herbicide-resistant plantlets could be useful
in saving resources and shortening the cycle of develop-
ment of new varieties.
The present study aimed to develop an efficient method
to select imidazolinone-resistant genotypes while shortening
breeding cycle. The objectives were to a) compare three
different techniques for obtaining plantlets from immature
sunflower embryos and b) evaluate different doses of ima-
zethapyr for the selection of genotypes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Plant material
Three sunflower inbred lines were used in this study: HA425B,
1058-1 and HA89B, which were described as imidazolinone resis-
tant (Imr
1
Imr
1
Imr
2
Imr
2
), intermediate (Imr
1
Imr
1
imr
2
imr
2
) and sus-
ceptible (imr
1
imr
1
imr
2
imr
2
), respectively (Bruniard 2001; Bruniard
®