New Approaches to Bourgeois Resistance in
Germany and Austria, 1933–1945
Eric Kurlander
Stetson University
Abstract
Middle class Protestants and Catholics constituted the largest single constituency in
the Third Reich, inclusive of Austria. Yet few historians in recent years have
examined the role of bourgeois resistance. Rather, contemporary scholarship tends
to emphasize the willingness of the German middle classes to accommodate National
Socialism (Anpassung), focusing almost exclusively on working class, women’s and
minority opposition (Resistenz or Verweigerung). The purpose of this article is to
offer some fruitful lines of inquiry that might help us to reassess the role of the
German and Austrian middle classes in resisting the Third Reich.
I. Introduction
In surveying Modern German historiography over the last thirty years,
Helmuth Walser Smith has observed, one might get the erroneous impression
that Jews constituted a majority of Germans, Catholics a near majority, and
Protestants an insignificant minority.
1
This statement holds equally true with
regard to the resistance against National Socialism. Middle class Protestants
represented the largest, most powerful constituency in the Third Reich.
Bourgeois and aristocratic Germans also engineered the most famous and
successful of resistance acts, the 20 July 1944 plot to assassinate Hitler. Yet
the lion’s share of research over the last thirty years has been devoted to
Jewish, Catholic, proletarian, and various other forms of subaltern resistance.
Moreover, despite the fact that virtually all documented cases of open
resistance (Widerstand) against the Third Reich occurred after March 1938
– that is, after the union (Anschluß) with Austria – none of these histories
integrate Austrian resistance into the wider narrative of domestic opposition
to National Socialism.
There are good reasons for such lacunae. Early research in both countries
was profoundly influenced by the Cold War. West German and
Anglo-American historians emphasized the central role of the Protestant
middle classes while East German historians argued that the working classes
alone had resisted in a meaningful way. In Austria few scholars wished to
question the exculpatory Moscow Declaration, promulgated by the Allies
© Blackwell Publishing 2006
History Compass 4/2 (2006): 275–292, 10.1111/j.1478-0542.2006.00307.x