Wetland use by brood-rearing female ducks in a
boreal forest landscape: the importance of food and
habitat
PETRI NUMMI,
1
* ANTTI PAASIVAARA,
2
SARI SUHONEN
1
& HANNU PÖYSÄ
3
1
Department of Forest Sciences, University of Helsinki, PO Box 27, Helsinki, FI-00014, Finland
2
Oulu Game and Fisheries Research, Finnish Game and Fisheries Research Institute, Tutkijatie 2 E, Oulu,
FI-90570, Finland
3
Joensuu Game and Fisheries Research, Finnish Game and Fisheries Research Institute, Yliopistokatu 6, Joensuu,
FI-80100, Finland
Habitat use by birds may be related to single or interacting effects of habitat characteris-
tics, food resources and predators, but little is known about factors affecting habitat use
by wetland species in boreal ecosystems. We surveyed brood-rearing females and duck-
lings of four common boreal duck species to assess the effects of habitat structure and
food resources on the use of wetlands by brood-rearing ducks. Although wetland use by
duck broods was related to habitat structure and food abundance, their relative impor-
tance varied among duck species. For the Common Goldeneye Bucephala clangula, a div-
ing duck, aquatic invertebrates and large emerging insects were the most important
factors associated with wetland use. Common Teal Anas crecca broods were observed
more often on wetlands with greater Dipteran emergence, whereas in Mallard Anas
platyrhynchos both habitat structure and large emerging insects were important. The
occurrence of Eurasian Wigeon Anas penelope broods was related to emerging Diptera
and habitat structure but the associations were not strong. The varying habitat and food
requirements of common duck species could influence the success of wetland manage-
ment programmes, and consideration of these factors may be particularly important for
initiatives aimed at harvested species or species of conservation concern.
Keywords: Anas crecca, Anas penelope, Anas platyrhynchos, aquatic invertebrates, Bucephala
clangula, emerging insects, habitat structure.
Understanding factors that affect the distribution of
species and individuals among habitats is crucial for
effective management and conservation. However,
associations between habitat structure and habitat
use may be difficult to interpret because different
habitat characteristics often act at the same time,
confounding the effects of individual factors (Petit
& Petit 1996, Chalfoun & Martin 2007). The
relative importance of food and habitat structure is
frequently addressed in studies of habitat selection
by birds (Wiens 1989, Preston 1990, Butler & Gil-
lings 2004) and some researchers have argued that
the importance of structure per se has been
overemphasized (Cody 1981, Terborgh 1985). Ter-
borgh (1985) pointed out that the ‘seductive corre-
lations’ found between birds and the structural
complexity of their habitat may be mere reflections
of some critical habitat features which are not read-
ily measured and which closely correlate with habi-
tat structure – of which food resources are a good
example (Halaj et al. 2000). Temporal variation in
critical resources may pose difficulties for birds that
must attempt to predict future habitat quality.
General habitat structure, for example, may be
detectable early in the breeding season, but not the
variation in insect food abundance and availability
(Hilden 1965, Orians & Wittenberger 1991).
Waterbirds live in environments where habitats
and resources are patchily distributed. In boreal
*Corresponding author.
Email: petri.nummi@helsinki.fi
© 2012 British Ornithologists’ Union
Ibis (2013), 155, 68–79