doi:10.1016/j.meddos.2009.10.006
CONFORMAL LOCOREGIONAL BREAST IRRADIATION WITH AN
OBLIQUE PARASTERNAL PHOTON FIELD TECHNIQUE
KATRIEN ERVEN, M.D., SASKIA PETILLION, M.SC., CAROLINE WELTENS, M.D., PH.D.,
FRANK VAN DEN HEUVEL,PH.D., GILLES DEFRAENE, M.ENG.,
ERIK VAN LIMBERGEN, M.D., PH.D., and WALTER VAN DEN BOGAERT, M.D., PH.D.
Department of Radiation Oncology, University Hospital Gasthuisberg, Leuven, Belgium
(Received 10 April 2009; accepted 26 October 2009)
Abstract—We evaluated an isocentric technique for conformal irradiation of the breast, internal mammary, and
medial supra-clavicular lymph nodes (IM-MS LN) using the oblique parasternal photon (OPP) technique. For 20
breast cancer patients, the OPP technique was compared with a conventional mixed-beam technique (2D) and a
conformal partly wide tangential (PWT) technique, using dose-volume histogram analysis and normal tissue
complication probabilities (NTCPs). The 3D techniques resulted in a better target coverage and homogeneity
than did the 2D technique. The homogeneity index for the IM-MS PTV increased from 0.57 for 2D to 0.90 for
PWT and 0.91 for OPP (both p < 0.001). The OPP technique was able to reduce the volume of heart receiving
more than 30 Gy (V
30
), the cardiac NTCP, and the volume of contralateral breast receiving 5 Gy (V
5
) compared
with the PWT plans (all p < 0.05). There is no significant difference in mean lung dose or lung NTCP between
both 3D techniques. Compared with the PWT technique, the volume of lung receiving more than 20 Gy (V
20
) was
increased with the OPP technique, whereas the volume of lung receiving more than 40 Gy (V
40
) was decreased
(both p < 0.05). Compared with the PWT technique, the OPP technique can reduce doses to the contralateral
breast and heart at the expense of an increased lung V
20
. © 2011 American Association of Medical Dosim-
etrists.
Key Words: Breast cancer, Internal mammary nodes, Radiotherapy, Treatment technique.
INTRODUCTION
Postoperative locoregional radiotherapy improves local
control and overall survival in node-positive breast can-
cer patients.
1
The complex target volume in locoregional
irradiation for breast cancer, in close proximity to the
heart and the lungs, renders treatment planning difficult,
because different fields have to be aligned to cover the
whole target. The dose distribution near the junction area
is often inhomogeneous, both at the skin surface and in
depth, which can lead to recurrences or complications. A
variety of treatment techniques for breast and internal
mammary and medial supraclavicular lymph node
(IM-MS LN) radiotherapy has been proposed, indicating
the absence of a generally accepted technique.
2
A widely used technique for irradiation of the breast
and the IM-MS LN, in the era before computed tomo-
graphy (CT)-based treatment planning, combines the
tangential breast fields with an anterior mixed photon
and electron beam, covering the IM-MS LN. The posi-
tion of the fields is mostly based on surface anatomy and
the dose is prescribed to a point.
3
It has been shown
that the whole target volume is not always covered
with this technique.
4
This is partly due to the lack of
consensus regarding the target volume definition in lo-
coregional breast cancer, and partly because of large
interpatient variability in position of the different target
volumes. Currently, guidelines for target volume delin-
eation are available and several studies support the use of
CT-based treatment planning in locoregional breast irra-
diation.
4–7
When a mixed photon and electron beam
technique is planned, based on full CT data, matchline
problems are highlighted. Adjacent fields can be de-
signed to overlap, to abut, or to allow a small gap to
optimise the target coverage. However, even with ade-
quate patient immobilization, there is no guarantee that
the overlap or gap can be reproduced consistently.
The subclavicular matchline problems can be
solved readily by using half beams for the tangential
fields and the supraclavicular field. Modern linear
accelerators enable this with asymmetric collimation.
8
The alignment between the tangential fields and the
parasternal field is a bigger challenge. In the partly wide
tangential (PWT) technique, the use of a parasternal match-
line is avoided by including the IM LN in the tangential
fields.
9
This technique was advocated in several compara-
tive planning studies as the most appropriate solution for
conformal irradiation of the breast and IM LN.
5,10 –12
A
disadvantage to this technique is the contralateral breast
dose.
To minimize matchline problems and avoid irradi-
ating the contralateral breast, the oblique parasternal
photon (OPP) technique is developed. This mono-isocentric
Reprint requests to: Katrien Erven, M.D., Department of Radia-
tion Oncology, University Hospital Gasthuisberg, Herestraat 49, 3000
Leuven, Belgium. E-mail: Katrien.Erven@uzleuven.be
Medical Dosimetry, Vol. 36, No. 1, pp. 28-34, 2011
Copyright © 2011 American Association of Medical Dosimetrists
Printed in the USA. All rights reserved
0958-3947/11/$–see front matter
28