Restrained Bending Fatigue Design of Bridge Cables
S.W. Khan
1
, and M. Raoof
1
1
School of Civil and Building Engineering, Loughborough University, Ashby Road,
Loughborough, Leics, United Kingdom, LE11 3TU; PH +44 (0)1509 222610
S.W.Khan@lboro.ac.uk, m.raoof@lboro.ac.uk
ABSTRACT
In previous work, certain shortcomings of traditional design approaches
against restrained bending fatigue of axially preloaded spiral strands used in cable
stayed structures (e.g. bridges) based on the extreme fibre direct stresses have been
identified and subsequently resolved. Restrained bending fatigue life of such spiral
strands clamped at the end(s), is shown to be governed by interlayer fretting fatigue.
Interlayer fretting is found to be greatest near the so-called neutral axis and not the
extreme fibre position, where, during tests, initial wire failures have invariably been
found to occur. A new parameter has thus been developed for design against such
rather common and often very costly fatigue failures. The reliability of any restrained
bending design procedure is based on a reasonably accurate estimation of the
minimum critical radii of curvature at the fixed end(s) with such values of curvature
then used as an input into the fatigue design model. The present paper makes
significant progress in resolving the longstanding debate in the literature as to
whether the traditional method of assuming a constant effective bending stiffness for
estimating such critical curvature(s) is a practically reasonable one.
Keywords: steel cables, bending stiffness, structural integrity, fatigue, bridges
INTRODUCTION
This paper is concerned with certain aspects of restrained bending fatigue
performance of realistic multilayered large diameter spiral strands Figure 1(a). Such
type of bending takes place in the absence of sheaves or other formers, so that the
radius of curvature of the strand is not predetermined. In the present terminology, the
term restrained bending fatigue refers to those cases where spiral strand fatigue
failures occur in the vicinity of partially or fully restrained terminations of various
types caused by hydrodynamic or aerodynamic cyclic loading. Such spiral strand
restrained bending fatigue failures are a source of concern in structures ranging from:
floating offshore platforms, suspension and cable-stayed bridges, the stays for guyed
masts, and electromechanical cables. In this context, it is worth mentioning that for
example, inspection of a large number of cable stayed bridges around the world has
revealed occurrence of corrosion and fatigue problems around the anchor joints of
cables (Watson and Stafford, 1988). In quite a few reported cases, cables (spiral
strands or locked coil ropes) of such bridges have had to be replaced.
In the course of design against such restrained bending fatigue failures, it is
common to introduce a mathematically convenient constant effective bending
stiffness EI
eff
, for the cable. By using EI
eff
, the minimum and most critical radii of
113 FORENSIC ENGINEERING 2012 © ASCE 2013
Forensic Engineering 2012
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Loughborough University on 12/27/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.