Selectively Cytotoxic Diterpenes from Euphorbia poisonii
Majekodunmi O. Fatope,
†
Lu Zeng, Joseph E. Ohayaga,
†
Guoen Shi, and Jerry L. McLaughlin*
Department of Medicinal Chemistry and Pharmacognosy, School of Pharmacy and Pharmacal Sciences, Purdue University,
West Lafayette, Indiana 47907, and Department of Chemistry, Bayero University, PMB 3011, Kano, Nigeria
Received July 13, 1995
X
Bioactivity-guided fractionation of the latex of Euphorbia poisonii Pax. (Euphorbiaceae) led to
the isolation and characterization of a new tigliane diterpene, 12-deoxyphorbol 13-(9,10-
methylene)undecanoate (3), together with five known diterpenes (1, 2, 4-6). When evaluated
for cytotoxicity in a panel of six human solid tumor cell lines, the diterpene esters, 1-3, 5, and
6, were selectively cytotoxic for the human kidney carcinoma (A-498) cell line with potencies
for 2 and 3 exceeding that of adriamycin by ten thousand times. Details of the isolations,
structural analyses, and cytotoxic activities are described.
There is a pervasive myth in northern Nigeria re-
garding the toxic nature of Euphorbia poisonii Pax.
(Euphorbiaceae), trivially called “Tinya” in Hausa.
Homicide deaths in rural communities are often at-
tributed to “Tinya” poisoning, the plant is not grazed
by livestock, and preparations made from its latex are
used as pesticides on millet farms. The latex of E.
poisonii is extremely irritant to human skin, and it
causes blindness when in contact with the eyes. The
chemistry
1-7
and bioactivity profiles
8-12
of compounds
previously isolated from E. poisonii have been studied
extensively. Certain phorbol esters, ingenol esters, and
daphnane derivatives isolated from Euphorbiaceous
plants have been demonstrated to have antileukemic
activities,
13
while lathyrane macrocyclics have been
reported as cytotoxic against tumor cells in culture.
14,15
Some phorbol esters have also been reported lethal to
brine shrimp, but phorbol itself showed no activity at
1000 µg/mL.
16
Our interest in E. poisonii derives from
several sources, among which are its uses as garden
pesticides in northern Nigeria and the paradoxical
activities of its latex components as both procarcinogenic
and antitumor agents. Fractionation of the latex of E.
poisonii, directed by the brine shrimp lethality test
(BST),
17,18
led to compounds 1-6 which were evaluated
for cytotoxicity in a panel of six human solid tumor cell
lines,
19-23
with adriamycin as a positive control. All of
these, except tigliane (4), showed strong cytotoxic
selectivity, with potencies approching ten thousand
times that of adriamycin, for the human kidney carci-
noma (A-498). In a previous paper, we described three
bioactive diterpenes that were similarly isolated from
the latex of E. poisonii but were less selectively cyto-
toxic.
24
Compound 3 is a novel tigliane diterpene
bearing an unusual 9,10-methyleneundecanoate ester
at position 13.
Results and Discussion
Previous studies
1-7
have reported the phytochemical
isolation of 12-deoxyphorbol esters and daphnane ortho
esters from the latex of E. poisonii. This and a previous
investigation
24
utilized the BST in an activity-directed
isolation project. The 10% aqueous MeOH soluble
fraction, of the latex extracts of this plant, exhibited a
modest activity against the brine shrimp larvae (LC
50
114 µg/mL). It also showed a significant selectivity for
certain cells when tested for cytotoxicity in a panel of
human solid tumor cell lines in culture. Bioactivity-
directed chromatographic fractionation of the bioactive
fraction gave 12-deoxyphorbol 20-acetate 13-angelate
(1),
1
12-deoxyphorbol 20-acetate 13-phenylacetate (2),
4
12-deoxyphorbol 13-(9,10-methylene)undecanoate (3),
20-hydroxy-12-deoxyphorbol angelate (4),
1
resiniferol
20-(4-hydroxy-3-methoxyphenylacetate) 9,13,14-ortho-
phenylacetate (5),
3,4,8
and 20-hydroxyresiniferol 9,13,-
14-orthophenylacetate (6).
4
The high-resolution mass spectroscopy (HRFABMS)
of, hitherto unreported, 3 suggested a molecular formula
of C
32
H
48
O
6.
Compound 3 has a UV maximum at 235
nm, indicating the presence of an R,-unsaturated
carbonyl group. Significant peaks in the CI-MS of 3 at
m/z 511, 313, and 294 identified the parent diterpene
skeleton as a 12-deoxyphorbol
9
with one acyl substitu-
ent. The m/z peak at 313 arose by the loss of H
2
O and
a fatty acid, with a mass unit of 198, from the molecular
ion. The
13
C-NMR data of 3 (Table 1) displayed a
tigliane skeleton, similar to 1, 2, and 4 (Chart 1),
together with a 12-carbon substituent at C-13. The
13
C-NMR spectrum also showed two trisubstituted
double bonds, one ketone and one ester carbon. The
molecular formula of 3 suggested the presence of a total
of nine unsaturation equivalents. Hence, the remaining
five unsaturation equivalents should be due to cyclic
forms.
The structure of the subsituent at C-13 of 3 was
determined by a careful analysis of the DEPT and
1
H-
NMR signals of the 12-carbon ester moiety. The pres-
ence of one methyl group, one ester carbonyl carbon,
two methines, and eight methylene carbons, one of
which resonated at δ 13.9, established an unusual
cyclopropane undecanoate structure for the 12-carbon
substituent. The exomethylene carbon was assigned to
C-9′,10′ because the
1
H-NMR spectrum of 3 showed one
tertiary methyl group at δ 0.89 (d, J ) 6.5 Hz) besides
that assigned to C-18. The carbon resonaces of the
cyclopropane ring (δ 23.3, 14.2, 13.9) and the tertiary
methyl group (δ 18.1) are comparable to those reported
for similar compounds (δ 27.6, 13.0, 12.4 for the cyclo-
propane ring and δ 19.2 for the attached methyl
group).
25,26
However, the stereochemistries of the cy-
clopropane ring could not be unequivocally assigned.
The NMR spectra of 5 and 6 showed the characteristic
†
Bayero University.
X
Abstract published in Advance ACS Abstracts, February 1, 1996.
1005 J. Med. Chem. 1996, 39, 1005-1008
0022-2623/96/1839-1005$12.00/0 © 1996 American Chemical Society