Determinants of Seclusion After
Aggression in Psychiatric Inpatients
Fleur J. Vruwink, Eric O. Noorthoorn, Henk L.I. Nijman,
Joanneke E.L. VanDerNagel, Joop J. Hox, and Cornelis L. Mulder
Some aggressive incidents in psychiatric wards result in seclusion, whereas
others do not. We used the Staff Observation Aggression Scale^Revised and
the mental health trust’s database to identify determinants that predicted
seclusion after aggression. These consisted of demographic, diagnostic,
contextual, and aggression characteristics and were analyzed in a multilevel
logistic regression. This showed associations between seclusion and aggres-
sion for the following: younger age, involuntary status, history of previous
aggression, physical or dangerous violence, aggression being directed
against objects, and a more severe incident. Thus, seclusion after aggres-
sion appears to be mainly predicted by aggression itself.
© 2012 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
B
ECAUSE SECLUSION SEEMS to be harm-
ful not only to psychiatric patients but also
to mental health nurses (Hoekstra, Lendemeijer, &
Jansen, 2004; VanDerNagel, Tuts, Hoekstra, &
Noorthoorn, 2009), Dutch mental health trusts and
psychiatric hospitals have increasingly started to
focus on reducing seclusion (Abma, Widdershoven,
& Lendemeijer, 2005; Landeweer et al., 2007).
For mental health nurses, seclusion could very
well compose a risk factor for work-related
mental burden and ultimately burnout symptoms
(VanDerNagel et al., 2009). By requiring consider-
able time to be devoted to the care of a single patient,
it also seems to disrupt ward routine and patient care.
Several international studies have shown that
seclusion is often preceded by aggressive incidents
(12%–100%, the trend being around 50%;
Demeestere, Abraham, & Moens, 1995; El-Badri
& Mellsop, 2002; Kaltiala-Heino, Tuohimaki,
Korkeila, & Lehtinen, 2003). However, not all
such incidents are followed by seclusion: two
European studies found that about half of the
aggressive incidents were followed by the use of a
coercive measure, usually seclusion (Abderhalden
et al., 2007; Nijman, Allertz, Merckelbach, a
Campo, & Ravelli, 1997). It is barely known
which characteristics determine whether aggression
is followed by seclusion. Staff's decision to
seclude a patient may be associated with the nature
and severity of the aggressive incident, but also a
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
Former affiliation where most work was done: Mediant
GGZ, Enschede, the Netherlands.
From the GGNet, Kenniscentrum, Warnsveld, the
Netherlands; Forensic psychology, Behavioural Science
Institute (BSI), Radboud University, Nijmegen, the
Netherlands; Altrecht Aventurijn, Den Dolder, the
Netherlands; Mediant GGZ Twente, Enschede, the
Netherlands; Social Science Methodology at the Faculty
of Social Sciences, University of Utrecht, Utrecht, the
Netherlands; Public Mental Health Research Center O3,
Erasmus MC Bavo Europoort, Mental Health Center
Rotterdam, Rotterdam, the Netherlands.
Corresponding Author: Fleur J. Vruwink, MD, GGNet,
Kenniscentrum, PO Box 2003, 7230 GC Warnsveld, the
Netherlands.
E–mail addresses: fleurvruwink@gmail.com
(F.J. Vruwink), e.noorthoorn@ggnet.nl
(E.O. Noorthoorn), h.nijman@altrecht.nl (H.L.I. Nijman),
je.vandernagel@mediant.nl (J.E.L. VanDerNagel),
j.hox@uu.nl (J.J. Hox), niels.clmulder@wxs.nl
(C.L. Mulder)
© 2012 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
0883-9417/1801-0005$34.00/0
doi:10.1016/j.apnu.2011.10.004
Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, Vol. 26, No. 4 (August), 2012: pp 307–315 307