PHYSICAL REVIEW B 87, 085402 (2013)
Electronic and magnetic properties of Fe clusters inside finite zigzag single-wall carbon nanotubes
F. I. Horga and A. Ma˜ nanes
*
Departamento de F´ ısica Moderna, Universidad de Cantabria, E-39005 Santander, Spain
M. J. L ´ opez and J. A. Alonso
Departamento de F´ ısica Te´ orica, At ´ omica y
´
Optica, Universidad de Valladolid, E-47011 Valladolid, Spain
(Received 15 August 2011; revised manuscript received 7 December 2012; published 4 February 2013)
Density functional calculations of the electronic structure of the Fe
12
cluster encapsulated inside finite single-
wall zigzag carbon nanotubes of indices (11,0) and (10,0) have been performed. Several Fe
12
isomers have
been considered, including elongated shape isomers aimed to fit well inside the nanotubes, and the icosahedral
minimum energy structure. We analyze the structural and magnetic properties of the combined systems, and
how those properties change compared to the isolated systems. A strong ferromagnetic coupling between the
Fe atoms occurs both for the free and the encapsulated Fe
12
clusters, but there is a small reduction (3–7.4 μ
B
)
of the spin magnetic moment of the encapsulated clusters with respect to that of the free ones (μ = 38 μ
B
).
The reduction of the magnetic moment is mostly due to the internal redistribution of the spin charges in the
iron cluster. In contrast, the spin magnetic moment of the carbon nanotubes, which is zero for the empty tubes,
becomes nonzero (1–3 μ
B
) because of the interaction with the encapsulated cluster. We have also studied the
encapsulation of atomic Fe and the growth of small Fe
n
clusters (n = 2, 4, 8) encapsulated in a short (10,0) tube.
The results suggest that the growth of nanowires formed by distorted tetrahedral Fe
4
units will be favorable in
(10,0) nanotubes and nanotubes of similar diameter.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.87.085402 PACS number(s): 73.22.−f, 73.63.Fg, 75.75.−c, 85.75.−d
I. INTRODUCTION
Carbon nanotubes encapsulating atoms, molecules, or
clusters have been synthesized, and their properties have
been analyzed, due to their fundamental and technological
interest. Nanotubes filled with Fe have potential uses in
medicine,
1
in spintronic devices,
2
including spin valves,
3
and
can also be used as probes for magnetic force microscopy.
4,5
Recent reviews on the preparation of filled carbon nanotubes
6,7
indicate the activity in the field. In general, free metallic
magnetic nanoparticles are oxide coated, but the encapsulation
of Fe clusters and nanowires in carbon nanotubes, where
these metallic nanostructures are protected from the oxidating
environment,
8
has been shown to be feasible.
9,10
The aim of this work is to present a theoretical study
of the electronic and magnetic properties of iron clusters
encapsulated in carbon nanotubes, using density functional
theory (DFT).
11
We shall focus on the Fe
12
cluster encap-
sulated inside finite pieces of single-wall zigzag nanotubes
(ZNTs) of indices (11,0) and (10,0). Finite zigzag nanotubes
have a peculiar magnetic structure: the ground state is an
antiferromagnetic (AFM) spin singlet S = 0. The local spin
polarization oscillates (spin up and spin down) along the
direction of the nanotube axis, and it is small, except at the two
ends of the nanotube, due to the existence of electronic states
localized at the edges of the nanotube. The two ends show
opposite orientation of the atomic magnetic moments.
12–15
Other states are close in energy to the ground state: magnetic
states (M) with net total magnetic moment μ
T
different from
zero (in some of these, the magnetic moments at the two edges
show the same orientation
13–15
), and a nonmagnetic (NM) state
showing local spin compensation along the nanotube. The
energy difference E(μ
0
T
) − E(AFM) between the lowest-lying
magnetic state (with total magnetic moment μ
0
T
) and the
ground state (AFM) decreases monotonically when the length
of the nanotube increases, up to a point where the difference
becomes lower than room temperature.
14
For the shortest
zigzag carbon nanotubes, E(μ
0
T
) − E(AFM) increases when
the diameter of the nanotube increases, showing an oscillating
effect.
16
Our aim is to analyze the interplay between the
singular magnetic properties of the finite ZNTs and the large
magnetization of the encapsulated Fe clusters. As we have
shown in a previous work,
15
the ZNTs present electronic
properties associated to edge states similar to those of zigzag
graphene ribbons,
17
therefore our study could be of relevance
in analyzing the properties of proposed magnetoresistive
devices based on zigzag graphene ribbons.
18
Furthermore, as
far as finite ZNTs can be considered as organic molecules
containing π electrons, our results can be useful in the
interpretation of the local spin polarization at the organic-
ferromagnetic interface, which has been recently described
both theoretically and experimentally.
19
Previous calculations of the electronic structure of
3d transition-metal atoms and clusters bonded to car-
bon nanostructures have considered infinitely long carbon
nanotubes,
20–28
an infinite graphene sheet,
26,29,30
capped finite
ZNTs,
31,32
or finite nanotubes with unsaturated open ends.
33
The effects due to the edge states have not been analyzed in
those works. The calculations indicate that the magnetism is
confined within the Fe aggregates, with a small reduction of
the magnetic moment per atom with respect to the free Fe
clusters. On the other hand, the magnetic moments per atom
result enhanced with respect to those of bulk Fe, due to the
reduced coordination of the metal atoms. In the particular
case of iron aggregates encapsulated in finite (8,0) nanotubes,
the calculations
33
indicate that the cluster is ferromagnetic,
with a total magnetic moment which is larger for the capped
tubes than for those with unsaturated open ends. Fujima
and Oda
32
have studied iron chains encapsulated in finite
capped (5,0) and (8,0) ZNTs. They found that the magnetism
085402-1 1098-0121/2013/87(8)/085402(12) ©2013 American Physical Society