A Clinical Trial with Brazilian Arnica (Solidago
chilensis Meyen) Glycolic Extract in the Treatment
of Tendonitis of Flexor and Extensor Tendons of
Wrist and Hand
Ary Gomes da Silva,
1
* Elbe Rodrigues Machado,
2
Leonardo Mendes de Almeida,
2
Ricardo Marcelo Menezes Nunes,
2
Patrícia Caldeira Pena Giesbrecht,
3
Regina Mamed Costa,
4
Helber B. Costa,
5
Wanderson Romão
5,6
and Ricardo Machado Kuster
7
1
Laboratory of Functional Ecology, University of Vila Velha—UVV, Brazil
2
Department of Pharmacy, University of Vila Velha—UVV-ES, Brazil
3
Department of Physiotherapy, University of Vila Velha—UVV-ES, Brazil
4
Doctoral Program in Biotechnology, Northeastern Web of Biotechnology—RENORBIO, Federal University of Espírito Santo—UFES, Brazil
5
Petroleomic and Forensic Laboratory, Department of Chemistry, Federal University of Espírito Santo—UFES, Brazil
6
Federal Institute of Espírito Santo, Vila Velha, IFES-ES, Brazil
7
Laboratory of Phytochemistry of Medicinal Plants, Institute of Natural Products Research, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro—
IPPN-UFRJ, Brazil
One of the Brazilian arnicas, Solidago chilensis Meyen, is a species of the Asteraceae family. This plant is known
by this common name because it shares remarkably similar organoleptic properties with the genus Arnica L., also
within the family Asteraceae. We examined the effectiveness of the S. chilensis fluid extract used externally for
treating tendinitis of flexor and extensor tendons of wrist and hand in placebo-controlled double-blind clinical
pharmacological studies. This study was approved by the Ethical Committee for Scientific Research in Human
Beings at University Vila Velha-UVV. Two daily skin applications on the arm skin of a gel cream containing a
5% glycolic plant extract were administered to eight volunteers for 21 days. Among the volunteers, one of their
arms was used as the placebo group, and the other one was used as a test group. Statistical data analyses demonstrated
a significant reduction in the perception of pain in the arms in the test group, when it was compared to those receiving
only the placebo. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Keywords: antiinflammatory; antinociception activity; repetitive strain injury; pain; phytotherapy; Asteraceae.
INTRODUCTION
Repetitive Strain Injuries (RSI), also found under the
nomenclature ‘Work-Related Muscle-skeletal Disease
(MSDs)’ can be defined as damage and/or a tissue suffer-
ing because of physical trauma. These affect preferably
upper limbs, including the neck, having necessarily occu-
pational origin, deriving from abuse and misuse of muscle
groups. In fact, RSI represent a heterogeneous group of
disorders of the musculoskeletal system that are related
to the job environment (Higgs and Mackinnon, 1995).
Sociologists and psychologists believe that RSIs are
somatic manifestations of distress of the current times,
in people with susceptible emotional profile. This collec-
tive hysteria can be unleashed by the organization of
modern work (Henderson and Bass, 2006). On the other
hand, anatomic and physiologic studies allow character-
izing RSI as an inflammatory process originated from
friction between bony structures, muscle, tendon, nerve,
and connective tissue, because of excessive, cumulative,
and repetitive movement of a body segment (Barbe and
Barr, 2006).
The repetitive stress has been associated with the in-
stallation of tenosynovitis, a process in which there is
an increase of synovial fluid, followed by inflammation
of the sheath formed by the synovial membrane that
covers and protects the tendon. As the initiator of this
process is the fact that some tendons change the direc-
tion on their way to perform a certain movement and,
for that, should remain close to the bone through the
fibrous structures called retinaculum. In these places,
the tendon undergoes compression or friction, which is
mitigated by the anatomical arrangement of the synovial
membrane that forms a sheath, protecting the tendon
slip. This sheath produces synovial fluid that lubricates
the tendon, reducing friction. Although tendons have,
in general, a robust vascular supply and nerve, tendon
regions subjected to friction, compression, or torsion
are avascular or hypovascularized, which contributes
to aggravate the injury in these areas. Repeated and
chronic inflammation leads to a hypertrophy of the
retinaculum, which becomes more fibrocartilaginous,
causing compression of the tendon beneath it, resulting
in tenosynovitis (Kamienski, 2013).
As the pain and inflammation are part of the tenosyno-
vitis framework, plants with recognized antiinflammatory
and analgesic properties have been popularly used to
treat this type of disorder, as is the case of many Brazilian
arnicas (Assini et al., 2013). However, little is known
* Correspondence to: Ary Gomes da Silva, Laboratory of Functional
Ecology, University of Vila Velha-UVV, Rua Comissário José Dantas de
Melo, 21, Boa Vista, Espírito Santo, CEP 29102-770, Brazil.
E-mail: arygomes@uvv.br
PHYTOTHERAPY RESEARCH
Phytother. Res. (2015)
Published online in Wiley Online Library
(wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI: 10.1002/ptr.5323
Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Received 06 July 2014
Revised 08 February 2015
Accepted 16 February 2015