Journal of Women and Minorities in Science and Engineering, vol. 12, pp. 95-117, 2006
ISSN 1072-8325/06/$35.00 Copyright © 2006 by Begell House, Inc. 95
UNDERGRADUATE WOMEN ENGINEERING THEIR
PROFESSIONAL IDENTITIES
Brenda M. Capobianco
Purdue University
In science education, the construct of identity has proven to be a useful tool for examining how students view
themselves as gendered and classed individuals, and how these identities intersect with their present and future science
participation. Yet, little is known about how young adult women studying engineering construct their own identities
as prospective engineers. In this study, which is part of a larger study involving an intervention designed to increase
retention of traditionally underrepresented students in engineering, I explored females’ personal and professional
identity construction throughout their undergraduate studies in engineering. Using a qualitative longitudinal case
study approach, I collected and analyzed interview data, WebCT interactions, and student work on modeling activities.
I developed a model of identity that emphasized the role of engineering in young women’s descriptions of who they are
as students and future engineers. Findings from this study could be useful in helping prospective and practicing science
and engineering educators develop academic programs, curriculum, and best practices.
INTRODUCTION
In today’s fast, growing world, researchers in a variety of areas have come to see
identity as an important analytic tool for understanding schools and society. In science
education, researchers have used the construct of identity to examine how students
view themselves as individuals and as participants in science (Brickhouse, Lowery, &
Schultz, 2000; Carlone, 2003, 2004); to understand how gender, race, and class interact
and contribute to young women’s marginalized identities in science (Brickhouse &
Potter, 2001); and to explore the dynamic relationship between science and a teacher’s
personal and professional identities (Helms, 1998). Results from these studies and
others (Kozol & Osborne, 2004) suggest that there is room for expansion in this line
of research. Introducing the notion of identity into other science-related ields, such as
engineering, to include both who the student is and who he or she wants to become,
affords researchers the opportunity to explore identity formation from undergraduate
academic communities to professional science communities.
In this study I chose to explore young women’s identity formation in engineering,
a ield of science where the representation of women and minorities has been very
low (Betz, 1994; Betz & Fitzgerald, 1987). While research efforts (DeBoer, 1984; Nauta,
Epperson, &Waggoner, 1999) have contributed to a greater understanding of the unique
career experiences of women in engineering, the number of women in engineering has
remained low, with fewer than 12% of professional engineers in recent years being
1
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Brenda M. Capobianco, Purdue University,
Department of Curriculum and Instruction, College of Education, 100 North University Street, West Lafayette,
Indiana, 47907-2098; e-mail bcapo@purdue.edu
This work was supported partially by NSF Grant 0120794-HRD. The author thanks the engineering students
who participated in this study; Kathryn Osburn, who assisted in the study; and the anonymous reviewers and
the editors of JWMSE for their suggestions on drafts of the manuscript.