1 3
Exp Brain Res
DOI 10.1007/s00221-015-4233-9
RESEARCH ARTICLE
(Dis-)Harmony in movement: effects of musical dissonance
on movement timing and form
Naeem Komeilipoor · Matthew W. M. Rodger ·
Cathy M. Craig · Paola Cesari
Received: 14 October 2014 / Accepted: 14 February 2015
© The Author(s) 2015. This article is published with open access at Springerlink.com
Introduction
We interact with our environment through movement;
with the way we move being influenced by many different
types of perceptual information. For instance, environmen-
tal sounds carry an ecological significance that allows us
to move in the direction of an object, detect the presence
of objects, interact with others and even interpret events
using sound alone (Gaver 1993; Carello et al. 2005). One
of the key ways in which humans naturally interact with
their auditory environment is when they synchronize their
movements to regular patterns of sound (e.g., dancing to
a beat). Indeed, to be able to synchronize movements to
sounds, an activity humans are very skilled at, the nerv-
ous system must pick up information from the auditory
perceptual stream about the time until the next beat sounds
and use this information to prospectively guide the genera-
tion of consecutive actions (Craig et al. 2005). Given the
absence of a continuous source of external temporal infor-
mation to guide the action extrinsically, the nervous system
must create its own source of dynamic temporal informa-
tion (Tau-G, Craig et al. 2005). It has already been shown
that the structure of sound events (discrete vs. continuous)
can affect the processes by which movements are timed to
sounds, even if the interval durations are the same (Rodger
and Craig 2011, 2013). Although synchronization of body
movement to the perceived musical tempo has been widely
studied (see Repp and Su 2013, for a review), the effects
of other aspects of auditory stimuli on movement–sound
synchronization, such as musical pitch relationships, have
largely been neglected.
Synchronizing movements with musical rhythms is
indeed one of the most natural and instinctive ways in which
humans interact with their auditory environment. The inex-
tricable link between sound and movement forms the basis
Abstract While the origins of consonance and dissonance
in terms of acoustics, psychoacoustics and physiology have
been debated for centuries, their plausible effects on move-
ment synchronization have largely been ignored. The pre-
sent study aimed to address this by investigating whether,
and if so how, consonant/dissonant pitch intervals affect
the spatiotemporal properties of regular reciprocal aiming
movements. We compared movements synchronized either
to consonant or to dissonant sounds and showed that they
were differentially influenced by the degree of consonance
of the sound presented. Interestingly, the difference was
present after the sound stimulus was removed. In this case,
the performance measured after consonant sound exposure
was found to be more stable and accurate, with a higher
percentage of information/movement coupling (tau cou-
pling) and a higher degree of movement circularity when
compared to performance measured after the exposure to
dissonant sounds. We infer that the neural resonance rep-
resenting consonant tones leads to finer perception/action
coupling which in turn may help explain the prevailing
preference for these types of tones.
Keywords Consonance dissonance sounds · Musical
pitch intervals · Sensorimotor synchronization
N. Komeilipoor (*) · P. Cesari
Department of Neurological and Movement Sciences,
University of Verona, Via Casorati 43, 37131 Verona, Italy
e-mail: naeem.komeilipoor@univr.it
N. Komeilipoor
MOVE Research Institute, VU University Amsterdam,
1081 BT Amsterdam, The Netherlands
M. W. M. Rodger · C. M. Craig
School of Psychology, Queen’s University Belfast, David Keir
Building, 18-30 Malone Road, Belfast BT9 5BN, UK