Evolution of fouling deposition and removal on hollow fibre membrane during
filtration with periodical backwash
Yun Ye, Vicki Chen ⁎, Pierre Le-Clech
UNESCO Centre for Membrane Science and Technology, University of New South Wales, 2052 Sydney, NSW, Australia
abstract article info
Article history:
Received 13 December 2010
Received in revised form 29 March 2011
Accepted 31 March 2011
Available online 27 April 2011
Keywords:
Direct observation
Hollow fibre membrane
Backwash
Air scouring
Fouling deposition and removal during filtration with short periodical backwash was investigated by direct
observation coupled with hydraulic resistance measurement. Using a model mixture of bentonite and
alginate, it was found that short periodical backwash only (i.e. without air scouring) expanded the foulant
cake, which is subsequently recompressed back to membrane surface when the filtration resumes. With air-
scouring aided backwash, the fouling material is convected away from the effective filtration zone, thus
limiting re-deposition. However, due to the potential fractionation of foulant species at high air scouring rate,
the deposition of more highly resistant components was observed over multiple filtration and backwash
cycles. The results indicated that the changes in cake height, composition and structure were affected not only
by the initial composition of the feed, but also by the hydrodynamics of the backwash and air scouring
present.
© 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Hollow fibre membrane systems are widely used in water and
wastewater treatment. However, this process is still limited by
membrane fouling, generally due to the cake formation or pore
blocking by particulate and macromolecular substances in the feed
water. Membrane fouling is commonly monitored by simple flux-
transmembrane pressure (TMP) measurements, and the fouling
resistance is calculated by using Darcy's law. Fouling mechanisms
such as cake filtration, pore blocking are inferred by applying different
filtration laws, but these laws are usually based on broad assumptions
regarding the uniformity of the particle/pore size and cake struc-
tures [1]. In reality, the heterogeneity of the foulant layers has been
shown in a number of previous studies [2,3]. Application of high and/or
turbulent shear via crossflow, gas sparging, and backwash (reversal of
permeate flow through the pores) are common physical approaches to
remove particulate and macromolecular foulants. However, there is
little detailed composition and structure information about foulant
nature and cake characteristics and how they evolve during cyclical
filtration and physical cleaning. These aspects are crucial to provide a
better understanding of the membrane fouling and mitigate the effects
of fouling to a sustainable level.
In the past decades, a number of non-invasive techniques have
been developed and applied to in-situ real-time monitoring of
membrane processes. These techniques include: direct observation
through the membrane (DOTM) [4–6], direct visual observation
(DVO) [7,8], nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) imaging [9], ultrasonic
time domain reflectometry (UTDR) [10] and direct observation using
laser sheet [3,11]. Most of the methods have focused on flat sheet
membranes, and only a limited number of studies have been carried out
with hollow fibre membranes [3,11–13].
Airey et al. [9] applied the NMR imaging technique to observe the
cake formation and dissipation of particle concentration polarization
layers on inside/out tubular membranes during the filtration of colloidal
silica suspensions at constant pressure. Their study provided the first
direct experimental evidence for a flowing concentration polarization
particle layer, obtained by means of a non-invasive technique. Recently,
Marselina et al. [13] adopted the DOTM method, originally developed
by Fane et al. [4], to visualize cake formation on the external surface of
hollow fibre membranes. Via direct observation (DO), the in-situ, real
time visualization and quantification of the cake height on the
membrane surface was measured, reducing some assumptions required
to estimate the specific cake resistance. The velocity profiles of particles
near the membrane surface during filtration could also be estimated
during the formation of stagnant and fluidised fouling layers [13].
Mendret et al. [3] also investigated the time variations of the thickness
and porosity of deposits on hollow fibres using an optical method with
laser sheet. For constant pressure operation, two different stages were
observed during the deposit thickness growth: first, a thin and dense
layer developed, and then a thicker and more permeable layer was
generally formed. Their study demonstrated the link between deposit
structure and process performance [3].
In addition to estimating cake height, the DO technique also
provides useful information on the membrane cleaning and foulant
removal. Mores and Davis [8] observed the fouling and cleaning of
Desalination 283 (2011) 198–205
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel.: + 61 2 9385 4813; fax: + 61 2 9385 5966.
E-mail address: v.chen@unsw.edu.au (V. Chen).
0011-9164/$ – see front matter © 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.desal.2011.03.087
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Desalination
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/desal