INSTITUTE OF PHYSICS PUBLISHING SUPERCONDUCTOR SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 14 (2001) R1–R27 www.iop.org/Journals/su PII: S0953-2048(01)08307-5
TOPICAL REVIEW
Charge- and spin-density-wave
superconductors
A M Gabovich
1,4
, A I Voitenko
1,4
, J F Annett
2
and M Ausloos
3
1
Crystal Physics Department, Institute of Physics, National Academy of Sciences,
prospekt Nauki 46, 03650 Kiev-28, Ukraine
2
University of Bristol, Department of Physics, H.H.Wills Physics Laboratory, Royal Fort,
Tyndall Avenue, Bristol BS8 1TL, UK
3
SUPRAS, Institut de Physique B5, Universit´ e de Li` ege, Sart Tilman, B-4000 Li` ege, Belgium
E-mail: collphen@iop.kiev.ua
Received 8 June 2000, in final form 14 January 2001
Abstract
This review deals with the properties of superconductors with competing
electron spectrum instabilities, namely, charge-density waves (CDWs) and
spin-density waves (SDWs). The underlying reasons of the electron
spectrum instability may be either Fermi surface nesting or the existence of
Van Hove saddle points for lower dimensionalities. CDW superconductors
include layered dichalcogenides, NbSe
3
, and compounds with the A15 and
C15 structures among others. There is much evidence to show that high-T
c
oxides may also belong to this group of materials. The SDW
superconductors include URu
2
Si
2
and related heavy-fermion compounds,
Cr–Re alloys and organic superconductors. We review the experimental
evidence for CDW and SDW instabilities in a wide range of different
superconductors, and assess the competition between these instabilities of
the Fermi surface and the superconducting gap. Issues concerning the
superconducting order parameter symmetry are also touched upon. The
accent is put on establishing a universal framework for further theoretical
discussions and experimental investigations based on an extensive list of
available and up-to-date references.
1. Introduction
The concept of a Fermi surface driven structural transition
due to the electron–phonon interaction (commonly called the
Peierls transition) has its roots in the 1930s [1], but only became
widely appreciated after the publication of the book Quantum
Theory of Solids [2]. At the same time, Fr ¨ ohlich [3] considered
a possible sliding of the collective state involving electrons and
lattice displacements in the one-dimensional (1D) metal as a
manifestation of the superconductivity. The emergent energy
gap was identified by him with a superconducting rather than
with the dielectric Peierls gap [1, 2] as it should be. Even
in the absence (practically inaccessible) of impurities, finite
phonon lifetimes, three-dimensional (3D) ordering and the
commensurability of the sliding wave with the background
crystal lattice [4–9], the Fr¨ ohlich 1D metal would have really
4
Corresponding authors.
become a so-called ‘ideal conductor’ with a zero resistance,
rather than a true superconductor exhibiting the Meissner and
Josephson effects [10, 11]. It is remarkable that the concept of
the electron spectrum energy gap in the superconducting state
had also been proposed by Bardeen [12] almost simultaneously
with Fr¨ ohlich and before the full microscopic Bardeen–
Cooper–Schrieffer (BCS) theory was developed [13].
The Fr¨ ohlich point of view [3] was revived after the
sensational discovery of the giant conductivity peak in the
organic salt TTF–TCNQ [14]. However, the coherent transport
phenomena appropriate to these quasi-1D substances appeared
to be a manifestation of a quite different collective state:
charge-density waves (CDWs) coupled with periodic lattice
distortions [4, 6, 8, 9, 15–18]. Their coherent properties now
constitute a separate interesting branch of solid-state science,
but lie beyond the scope of our review and will be touched
upon hereafter only in specific cases where necessary. Here we
0953-2048/01/040001+27$30.00 © 2001 IOP Publishing Ltd Printed in the UK R1