European Journal of Epidemiology 10: 291-297, 1994.
© 1994 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
The evolution of pulmonary tuberculosis in coal miners in Asturias,
Northern Spain
An attempt to reduce the rate over a 15-year period, 1971-1985
J.A. Mosquera l, L. Rodrigo 2 & F. Gonzfilvez 3
1Department of Pulmonary Medicine, 2 Department of Internal Medicine, 3 Department of Thoracic Surgery,
Institutio Nacional de Silicosis, Ovieto, Spain
Accepted in revised form 22 April 1994
Abstract. A prospective study of 53,753 coal miners
was undertaken at the Instituto Nacional de Silicosis
(INS) in Asturias, Spain, during the period 1971 to
1985. This included a complete medical history,
physical examination, pulmonary function tests, and
intensive search for pulmonary tuberculosis. A total
of 1,136 new cases of active pulmonary tuberculosis
were found, all of which were confirmed by bacteri-
ology. The average incidence was 150 + 31 cases per
100,000 miners year-1. Annual analysis revealed that
this figure remained fairly stable during the period
of study. Only a reduction of the prevalence in the
subgroup of miners with massive pulmonary fibrosis
was seen in later years. The risk of tuberculosis
among miners was three times greater than that for
the general population of the same area. Our inability
to reduce the incidence of pulmonary tuberculosis
in a large group of coal miners, in spite of the fact
that the treatments given were effective and that in
the last eight years chemoprophylaxis was given to
close contacts, should be emphasized.
Key words: Coal workers pneumoconiosis, Progressive massive fibrosis (PMF), Silicotuberculosis,
Tuberculosis
Introduction
Different studies employing mortality indexes and
rates of infection have been carried out on the epi-
demiology of pulmonary tuberculosis. These have
permitted the formulation of the hypothesis of a
probable rapid disappearance of the disease, at least,
in more industrialized Western countries [1, 2]. When
we carefully analyse the data based on the rates of
disease in recent years, conclusions can be drawn that
if the prevalence of tuberculosis (TB) continues at its
present rate, this disease and the increment of such
seen in patients with AIDS and other debilitating
diseases will not disappear in the near future [3].
A well-known double interaction exists between
pulmonary tuberculosis and pneumoconiosis in coal
workers. On the one hand, pulmonary silicosis
implies an increased risk of suffering pulmonary
tuberculosis, probably as a consequence of coal par-
ticles inhaled into the alveoli of the lung, with later
destruction by phagocytes. On the other hand, the
appearance of pulmonary tuberculosis in the course
of coal worker pneumoconiosis induces the progres-
sion toward a picture of progressive massive fibrosis
(PNF) [4]. This consequently implies the transfor-
mation of uncomplicated forms of TB with little or
no functional effect and good life expectancy, into
complicated pneumoconiosis with a decrease of res-
piratory pulmonary capacity and the appearance of
multiple complications that shorten the life
expectancy of these patients [5-7].
In our experience pulmonary tuberculosis is the
commonest cause of complicated pneumoconiosis
in coal workers. Thus any attempt to reduce its
incidence is based on early detection and efficient
treatment of the disease with currently available
drugs. The aim of the present work was to analyse
the evolutive data of the incidence of pulmonary
tuberculosis in a relatively stable coal mining
population over a period of time (in our case fifteen
years), and also to evaluate the effectiveness of the
different types of treatment used throughout the
period of the study.
Material and methods
Asturias is located in northeast Spain and has a stable
population of around one million two hundred
thousand people. One of its main industrial activi-
ties is coal mining. During the study period, an
average of 29,949 + 1,413 persons were employed
in this activity. The number of people who formerly
worked in the mines and who were, at the time,
retired was 21,522 + 7,368, all of whom constitute
the target population under analysis (Figure 1).