Abstract Introduction: The standard treatment for patients
who require total hip replacement is the implantation of
an intramedullary diaphyseal anchored hip prosthesis.
A bone-sparing thrust plate hip prosthesis (TPP) can be
used as an alternative device for young patients. The TPP
relies on proximal femoral metaphyseal fixation. The the-
oretical advantage of leaving diaphyseal bone intact is
easier conversion to a stemmed prosthesis. This retrospec-
tive study evaluated the medium- and short-term results
after total joint replacement using the third generation
TPP. Materials and methods: Between 1997 and 2001, 58
TPPs were used for 52 patients. Clinical and demographic
data were obtained from the patients’ charts and our elec-
tronic database. Their average age at time of surgery was
40.9±11.4 years. At follow-up, the Harris hip score, resid-
ual pain, required pain medication, and the ability to lie on
the operated side were documented. Radiographic evalua-
tion included standardized radiographs of the hip joint and
the pelvis. Results: Four patients required revision surgery
(6.9%). For 51 of the remaining 54 TPPs, a postoperative
functional and radiological status was obtained. The aver-
age follow-up was 26±11.0 months. 88% of the patients
experienced some or complete relief of pain. The median
Harris hip score at follow-up was 73±20.5 points. A post-
operative hip dislocation occurred in 5 patients (8.6%).
Conclusion: Since many patients experienced some or
complete relief of pain, the TPP can be recommended as a
feasible implant for the treatment of hip disorders requir-
ing total hip arthroplasty in young patients. Revision sur-
geries are facilitated by the good bone stock remaining in
the proximal femur.
Keywords Osteoarthritis of the hip · Thrust plate
prosthesis · Harris hip score · Total hip arthroplasty
Introduction
The treatment of young patients with hip disorders requir-
ing total hip arthroplasty is challenging. Since the average
survival rate of total hip arthroplasties is roughly 10–15 years,
most young patients can require multiple revision sur-
geries. Therefore, an implant that minimizes bone stock loss
at the index procedure would present a theoretical advan-
tage. A hip prosthesis that relies on metaphyseal fixation
without affecting diaphyseal bone has been developed by
Huggler and Jacob [13]. This thrust plate hip prosthesis
(TPP; -SulzerMedica) is shown in Fig. 1. The first im-
plantation of a TPP was performed in 1978 [14, 15]. The
force transfer with this prosthesis is biomechanically sim-
ilar to the normal physiologic state [16, 17], minimizing
the postoperative bone remodeling in the proximal femur
[13, 16, 17].
Although the TPP has been used since 1978, there are
few clinical outcome reports [7, 8, 14]. The aim of this
study was to evaluate the medium- and short-term results
after TPP implantation and to assess clinical and radio-
graphic variables that are predictive of the outcome.
Patients and methods
Between 1997 and 2001, 58 prostheses (29 right/29 left) were im-
planted into 52 patients (33 male/19 female). Their average age at
the time of surgery was 40.9±11.4 years. Indications for implanta-
tion are shown in Fig. 2. Thirty-one patients had undergone previ-
ous surgery prior to TPP implantation (Table 1). For the 25 pa-
tients with posttraumatic osteoarthritis, the time between injury
and TPP implantation was 5.6±7.2 years. Seventeen patients had
sustained an acetabular fracture; five patients had sustained a
femoral head or neck fracture; and three patients had a fracture of
both components. For patients with femoral head avascular necro-
Boris A. Zelle · Torsten G. Gerich · Leonard Bastian ·
Franklin D. Shuler · Hans-Christoph Pape ·
Christian Krettek
Total hip arthroplasty in young patients using the thrust plate prosthesis:
clinical and radiological results
Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (2004) 124 : 310–316
DOI 10.1007/s00402-004-0652-y
Received: 4 March 2003 / Published online: 14 April 2004
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
B. A. Zelle · T. G. Gerich · L. Bastian · H.-C. Pape · C. Krettek
Department of Trauma Surgery, Hannover Medical School,
Hannover, Germany
B. A. Zelle · F. D. Shuler
Department of Orthopaedics,
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, PA, USA
B. A. Zelle (✉)
327 McKee Place, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA
Tel.: 412-628-8014, Fax: 412-687-3724,
e-mail: zelleba@msx.upmc.edu
© Springer-Verlag 2004