Article
Restructuring the welfare state: reforms in long-term care in Western
European countries
Emmanuele Pavolini, University of Macerata, Italy
Costanzo Ranci*, Polytechnic of Milan, Italy
Summary Faced with the problems associated with an ageing society, many European countries
have adopted innovative policies to achieve a better balance between the need to expand social
care and the imperative to curb public spending. Although embedded within peculiar national
traditions, these new policies share some characteristics: (a) a tendency to combine monetary
transfers to families with the provision of in-kind services; (b) the establishment of a new social
care market based on competition; (c) the empowerment of users through their increased pur-
chasing power; and (d) the introduction of funding measures intended to foster care-giving
through family networks. This article presents the most significant reforms recently introduced
in six European countries (France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Sweden and the UK) as
regards long-term care. It analyses their impact at the macro- (institutional and quantitative),
meso- (service delivery structures) and micro-level (families, caregivers and people in need). As a
result the authors find a general trend towards convergence in social care among the countries,
and the emergence of a new type of government regulation designed to restructure rather than to
reduce welfare programmes.
Key words ageing, long-term care, privatization, social care, welfare state restructuring
Current changes in long-term care
The development of long-term care (LTC) services
constitutes one of the main testing grounds for the
innovative capacities of Western European welfare
systems, which in their current state are in fact
largely unable to satisfy the needs of an increasing
number of care-dependent people (Martin, 2001).
To date, dependence has been a social risk not
adequately covered by welfare systems. Traditional
forms of public protection provided care-dependent
citizens with invalidity pensions and health and
rehabilitation services. While government insurance
schemes for chronically ill people are generally not
sufficient to meet the huge costs of LTC, health serv-
ices are still designed mainly to deal with the acute
phases of disease, not to assist dependent people for
long periods of time.
The inadequate growth of LTC programmes has
become increasingly apparent as the number of
people who are dependent has grown.
1
These pro-
grammes still receive very limited funding. At the
same time there has been a progressive decrease in
the ability of family networks to provide support
owing to the increase in the old age dependency
ratio and the female activity rate.
Faced with the dilemma of these growing demands
for services and the need to contain the costs of care
provision, many Western European governments have
reformed their LTC services over the last 15 years. The
purpose of this article is to describe these changes and
to provide a general interpretation of the direction
*Author to whom correspondence should be sent: Costanzo Ranci, Polytechnic of Milan, via Bonardi, 3, 20133 Milano,
Italy. [email: costanzo.ranci@polimi.it]
Journal of European Social Policy 0958-9287; Vol 18(3): 246–259; 091058 Copyright © SAGE Publications 2008, Los Angeles, London,
New Delhi and Singapore, DOI: 10.1177/0958928708091058 http://esp.sagepub.com
at Biblioteca Scienze Politiche on November 10, 2015 esp.sagepub.com Downloaded from