DOI: 10.1007/s00339-008-4451-0
Appl. Phys. A 92, 83–89 (2008)
Materials Science & Processing
Applied Physics A
e. bernardi
1
c. chiavari
2, ✉
c. martini
2
l. morselli
1
The atmospheric corrosion of quaternary
bronzes: An evaluation of the dissolution
rate of the alloying elements
1
Dipartimento di Chimica Industriale, Università di Bologna, V. le Risorgimento 4, 40136 Bologna, Italy
2
Dip. Scienza dei Metalli, Elettrochimica e Tecniche Chimiche (SMETEC), Università di Bologna,
V. le Risorgimento 4, 40136 Bologna, Italy
Received: 5 September 2007/Accepted: 15 January 2008
Published online: 27 March 2008 • © Springer-Verlag 2008
ABSTRACT A comparative evaluation of the corrosion be-
haviour of a G85 bronze in acid rain solutions was performed.
As weathering technique, a wet–dry device was used to simu-
late a cyclic exposure to stagnant rain. The weathering solutions
were a collected natural rain and an artificial solution reproduc-
ing the natural rain. The solutions were periodically monitored
as concerns pH and metallic ion concentrations. On the aged
specimens, surface studies were performed through OM, SEM
and Raman analyses. At the end of weathering tests (40 days),
weight loss measurements were carried out.
The aim of this work was to examine the reproducibility in
laboratory of the corrosive conditions determined by a natural
acid rain. The final goal of this research is to investigate the
dissolution of a quaternary alloy exposed to acid rains.
The results showed slightly different corrosion behaviours
as a consequence of the exposure to natural or synthetic rain.
Concerning the mechanism of corrosion of G85 bronze, the in-
novative approach adopted in this study allowed one to point out
the contribution of each alloying element to the general corro-
sion. Actually, while Cu and Pb progressively form insoluble
corrosion compounds, Zn continuously dissolves, without form-
ing detectable insoluble products. The absence of dissolved tin
is remarkable.
PACS 82.45.Bb; 82.33.Tb; 92.40.Ea
1 Introduction
The corrosion behaviour of outdoor bronzes was
the subject of many studies in the field of atmospheric corro-
sion [1–9].
Up to now, accelerated corrosion tests have been per-
formed in laboratories through the exposition of copper-based
material to environments simulating the depositions of urban
areas. Nevertheless, an artificial solution could hardly repro-
duce the complexity of a real deposition. Then, with an inno-
vative approach, a comparative investigation on the corrosion
behaviour of the bronze exposed both to natural acid rains and
✉ Fax: +39-51-2093467, E-mail: cristina.chiavari@unibo.it
to analogous synthetic rains has started to be performed [10].
The aim of this work was to examine the reproducibility in
laboratory of the corrosive conditions determined by a natu-
ral acid rain. The final goal of this research is to investigate the
dissolution of a quaternary alloy exposed to natural acid rains.
Actually, the use of natural rain as an ageing solution im-
plies many complications related to the low volumes collected
and to the low concentration of the pollutant components. In
fact, the scarcity of volume is a limiting aspect for the selec-
tion of the most appropriate weathering technique, that should
require modest quantities of solution, possibly not to be re-
newed. Moreover, the low concentration of pollutants in the
real solutions can determine an extension of the time needed
for the observation of corrosion phenomena, increasing the
possibility of degradation of the solution itself. Considering
all these points, we chose the wet–dry technique or alternate
immersion as weathering method.
In a preliminary study [10], a different behaviour was no-
ticed between bronze specimens aged in natural rain and the
ones aged in the analogous synthetic rain, not including the
organic components. The necessity of considering organic
compounds as factors influencing the dissolution behaviour of
copper-based materials is perceived in literature [11–13].
In this work, in order to comprehend the causes of these
discrepancies, a new comparison has been performed, be-
tween the natural rain and the artificial one enriched of the
main organic components (HCOO
−
, CH
3
COO
−
) as well as of
the aggressive inorganic components, H
+
, Cl
−
, NO
−
3
, NH
+
4
,
SO
2−
4
.
The wet–dry technique was used as a weathering method
simulating exposure to a stagnant liquid (no run-off is con-
sidered in this study, i.e., the specimens were cyclically im-
mersed in the same weathering solution at each cycle). The
two weathering solutions were monitored periodically, focus-
ing on the changes of both pH and metallic ion concentrations.
On the aged specimens, analyses were carried out in order
to characterize the corrosion patina. Weight loss measure-
ments were performed at the end of weathering tests. Whereas
the weight loss measurements give information on the gen-
eral corrosion processes, the determination of the metallic ion
concentration in the solution allows the calculation of a disso-
lution factor for each alloying component. By this method, the