Efficient Implementation of Short Fundamental
Equations of State for the Numerical Simulation of
Dense Gas Flows
P. Cinnella
*
and S.J. Hercus
†
Arts et M´ etiers ParisTech, Paris 75013, France
An artificial neural network (ANN) of the multi-layer perceptron (MLP) type is used
to generate an explicit auxiliary thermodynamic equation, whose mathematical form is
particularly well suited for implementation within Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)
solvers. This equation directly relates the thermodynamic quantity of interest (tempera-
ture) to the conservative variables (density, momentum per unit volume, total energy per
unit volume), via the density ρ and the internal energy per unit volume ρe. The resulting
relationship, of the form T = T (ρ, ρe), is added to the usual thermal and caloric equations
of state, in order to avoid expensive iterative computations of the temperature. We select
15 dense gases of industrial interest, whose thermodynamic properties can be described
by the 12-parameter Span-Wagner fundamental equation. The accuracy and computa-
tional cost of the proposed formulation are verified a priori, via detailed comparisons with
data provided by the baseline thermodynamic model, and a posteriori, by propagating the
approximated thermodynamic model through a numerical flow simulation. Results are
shown for transonic dense gas flows through a two-dimensional turbine cascade, for sample
thermodynamic conditions close to the saturated vapor line. A 53% average reduction in
computation time is observed, and the convergence and numerical stability of the numerical
solution is greatly enhanced, while deviations less than 3% are observed on the computed
quantities of interest with respect to the baseline solver.
Nomenclature
f Physical flux vector
v Velocity vector
w Conservative variable vector
δ Reduced density, ρ/ρ
c
Δ
sat
Saturation curve error [%], 100(T
sat
Aux.
− T
sat
SW
)/T
sat
SW
Δ
i
Local error [%], 100(T
Aux.,i
− T
SW,i
)/T
SW,i
, over the i =1,...,N points of the validation mesh
˙ m
2D
Mass flow rate per unit depth
ǫ Error [%], 100(ν
Aux.
− ν
SW
)/ν
SW
, for the turbine performance parameters ν =[η
s
,˙ m
2D
, P
2D
]
η
s
Isentropic turbine efficiency, Δh
real
/Δh
is
µ Mean value, calculated over the 15 fluids considered in this work
ω Acentric factor
Φ Gibbs free energy
φ Reduction [%] in calculation time, 100(t
SW
− t
Aux.
)/t
SW
Ψ Helmholtz free energy
ψ Reduced Helmholtz energy
ρe Internal energy per unit volume
ρ Density
σ Modeling uncertainty, %
*
Professor, Laboratoire DynFluid, 151 Bd de l’Hˆ opital, Paris 75013, France
†
Research Engineer, Laboratoire DynFluid, 151 Bd de l’Hˆ opital, Paris 75013, France
1 of 27
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
42nd AIAA Thermophysics Conference
27 - 30 June 2011, Honolulu, Hawaii
AIAA 2011-3947
Copyright © 2011 by Paola Cinnella and Samuel Hercus. Published by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc., with permission.