River, Coastal and Estuarine Morphodynamics: RCEM 2007 – Dohmen-Janssen & Hulscher (eds)
© 2008Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-45363-9
Meandering channel dynamics in highly cohesive sediment on an
intertidal mud flat
Wiecher Bakx, Filip Schuurman, Maarten G. Kleinhans & Henk Markies
Universiteit Utrecht, Fac. Geosciences, Dept. Physical Geography, Utrecht,The Netherlands
ABSTRACT: On an intertidal mud flat in the Western Scheldt estuary (the Netherlands), small meandering
channels (about 1 m wide) were studied with the aim to improve understanding of the effect of highly cohesive
sediment on channel and meander geometry and dynamics. The morphology of several channels was mapped
repeatedly using stereo photography. During a neap-spring tidal cycle the flow velocity and sediment concentra-
tion was measured in detail in one meandering channel. Grain size analysis showed that the mud consists of about
equal portions of clay and silt plus fine sand. Laboratory flume experiments were done on a carefully installed
bed of sediment from the Western Scheldt intertidal flat. Three processes dominate erosion and morphodynam-
ics of the meandering channels: 1) splash-erosion by rain, 2) erosive steps under hydraulic jumps and 3) bank
erosion in very sharp bends in addition to the usual common bank erosion by undercutting. The flow velocity
during flooding is negligible compared to the ebb flow. Rain storms at low tide cause much larger morphological
change and sediment concentrations than the diurnal tide-related change and concentrations, even though the
tidal discharge volume is larger than the rain runoff. Also storms cause larger morphological change, probably
because of sediment stirring by gravity waves. Laboratory experiments with rainfall simulations verified that
splash erosion by rain-drops breaks down the cohesive structure of the consolidated clay, resulting in an easy
erodible surface layer of fluid mud.We hypothesise that the smaller, upstream channels in the channel network
on the intertidal flat are generated by high-concentration, channelising rainfall runoff. Vertical downward steps
ranging 0.01–0.1 m in height were observed particularly in the sections with steeper slopes near the low-tide
base level of the Western Scheldt main channel adjacent to the intertidal flat.At these times the flow discharge
sources were rainfall runoff and base flow, causing critical flow conditions with discharges far below bankfull.
The steps occur under highly erosive hydraulic jumps and migrate upstream, resulting in the excavation of the
thalweg and undercutting of the banks as confirmed in preliminary laboratory flume experiments. Very sharp
meander bends with R/W < 2 are common while meander cutoffs are rare. Dye tracer experiments in several
meander bends at bankfull discharge revealed recirculating flows in two places: just downstream of the apex in
the inner bend and just upstream of the apex in the outer bend. Thus, the main flow impinges on the bank of the
outer bend, causing the bank erosion pattern that leads to the sharp meander in agreement with literature. We
discuss a simple extension of a meander simulation model to include very sharp bends.
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Scope and aim
Intertidal mud flats commonly have small meandering
streams (e.g Fagherazzi et al. 2004). Since mean-
dering dynamics strongly depend on the strength of
river banks, these meandering channels are inter-
esting exemplars in the more cohesive part of the
spectrum from noncohesive to very cohesive banks.
The channels are so small that they could poten-
tially be recreated in a laboratory flume. However,
earlier attempts to do so proved that the meanders
arrest after some time and become fixed in planform
(e.g. Smithm, 1998). Dynamic meandering in cohesive
sediment has not been reproduced in the laboratory
because the unscaled cohesion is too large compared
to the downscaled laboratory channels. However, the
similar-sized meandering channels on intertidal flats
are dynamic (pers. comm. with locals at our field site,
and Fagherazzi et al. (2004)).
The aim of this paper is to identify the main mech-
anisms for meander dynamics on a cohesive intertidal
mud flat. We study natural meander geometry and
dynamics during a neap-spring tide cycle, and study
erosive processes in more detail on natural mud in a
laboratory flume. We found three processes that dom-
inate erosion and morphodynamics of the meandering
channels: splash erosion, erosive backward migrating
763