Moving from a universal to targeted child health
programme: which children receive enhanced care?
A population-based study using routinely
available data
R. Wood,* D. Stockton* and H. Brown†
*Information Services Division, NHS National Services Scotland, Edinburgh, UK, and
†The Roslin Institute and Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Studies, University of Edinburgh, Midlothian, UK
Accepted for publication 24 May 2012
Keywords
deprivation, health
promotion, needs
assessment, pre-school
children, service
provision, surveillance
Correspondence:
Rachael Wood,
Information Services
Division, NHS National
Services Scotland, Gyle
Square, 1 South Gyle
Crescent, Edinburgh
EH12 9EB, UK
E-mail:
rachaelwood@nhs.net
Abstract
Background There is a current emphasis on ‘progressive universal’ delivery of the UK child health
programme, with a core universal service complemented by enhanced support provided according
to need. In Scotland, a three-category indicator of need, the ‘Health Plan Indicator’ (HPI) is used to
identify children requiring enhanced support from the child health programme to facilitate this.
Methods Routine child health programme and hospital delivery records for a cohort of 36 871
Scottish children were used to explore the factors associated with being identified as requiring
enhanced child health programme support using multilevel logistic regression modelling.
Results The following factors were all independently associated with an increased likelihood of
being assessed as requiring enhanced support: (i) deprivation; (ii) young maternal age, maternal
smoking and drug misuse; (iii) a previous stillbirth; (iv) prematurity; (v) being small for gestational
age; (vi) no breastfeeding, admission to a special care baby unit; and (vii) medical, social or
developmental concerns about the baby.There was a tendency for children living in areas with
higher Health Visitor staffing levels to be more likely to be assessed as requiring enhanced support
but this effect was not statistically significant. There was significant residual variation between areas
in the likelihood of children being assessed as requiring enhanced support.
Discussion This study suggests Health Visitors take a complex range of factors into account when
assessing which children require enhanced support from the child health programme. Health
Visitors’ workload may influence the likelihood of them identifying children as requiring enhanced
support but this requires further clarification. There are clear differences between areas in allocation
of the different HPI categories. Further work is required to explore the relationship between being
identified as in need of enhanced support, the care actually provided to children, and their
outcomes.
Introduction
Children’s early experiences are powerful influences on their
long-term health and development (Shonkoff & Phillips 2000;
Shore 2003; Hertzman & Boyce 2010; Marmot 2010). In recog-
nition of the importance of the early years, the UK has a long
history of providing a structured child health programme to all
families (Committee on Child Health Services 1976). The pro-
gramme for pre-school children comprises various elements
including growth and development surveillance, health promo-
tion and parenting support (Blair & Hall 2006). Delivery of these
elements of the programme is founded on repeated contacts
Child:
care, health and development
Original Article doi:10.1111/j.1365-2214.2012.01423.x
© 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 1