practice
JOURNAL OF WOUND CARE VOL 24, NO 1, JANUARY 2015 140
© 2015 MA H EALTHCARE LTD
A new quality of life consultation
template for patients with venous
leg ulceration
chronic venous leg ulceration; quality of life; wound care; template; consultation
C
hronic venous leg ulcers (CVLUs)
impact signiicantly on every area of
patient functioning (Fig 1);
1
and yet,
despite these wide-ranging effects,
patients are reluctant to disclose the
extent of their dificulties to their district nurse
(DN).
2
Theories relating to the personal characteris-
tics of patients attempt to explain their responses to
chronic conditions which include a reluctance to
disclose key factors, an unwillingness to relinquish
control to the nurse and, for some, a lack of coping
with the perceived consequences of the condition.
3–5
Research that explores patient-centred care
(PCC), although limited, purports positive beneits
for patients who engage with care including opti-
mised participation, enhanced satisfaction, posi-
tive clinical outcomes and improvements in quali-
ty of life (QoL).
6–9
Health-care professionals (HCPs)
are also shown to beneit from a PCC approach to
care with reports of enhanced personal empower-
ment and increased job satisfaction.
10,11
Despite
such beneits, research suggests that practitioners
continue to fail to elicit patients’ main concerns
during consultations and many patients remain
reluctant to disclose key factors relating to their
condition and/or care.
2,9–11
Thorne
12
highlights that
HCP and patient communication is an important
opportunity within the consultation, with effec-
tive dialogue having the potential to optimise
autonomy and maintain independence.
13,14
In the light of such research and in order to ensure
such key QoL issues for people with CVLUs receive
appropriate attention during future consultations, a
new, evidence-based and patient-focused template
has been developed using a nominal group (NG)
approach. The intention of this template is to
encourage the consulting nurse to explore appropri-
ate themes,
1,2
to encourage the patient to engage in
their care,
6
to make sense of their condition
4,15
and
to build a concordant relationship with their
HCP.
3,5,16
In this paper we report on the develop-
ment, in conjunction with experts and patients, of
a template to focus consultations on these patient-
disclosed themes.
Background
This study has four overall phases, with phases 1
and 2 reported in earlier articles.
1,2
In phase 1 factors
of importance to people with CVLUs were system-
atically identiied during unstructured interviews
(n=9; Fig 1).
1
During phase 2,
2
the wound care consultations of
the same study participants (n=5) were observed on
20 occasions and a checklist based on the phase 1
indings was completed to identify the extent to
which experienced nurses addressed the factors
raised during the patient interviews. Data from
these observations was analysed descriptively
2
and
revealed that 38% of patient concerns were not
raised, a further 38% were either overlooked by the
nurse or discussed without any change in care and
only 24% of patients’ were offered a partial or com-
plete solution to their problems.
2
These phases con-
stituted preparatory work for the development of
this consultation template and full details have
formed the basis of earlier publications.
1,2
l
Objective: Chronic venous leg ulcers (CVLUs) are common and recurrent, however, care for patients
predominantly has a focus which overlooks the impact of the condition on quality of life.The aim of this
study was to develop a simple, evidence-based consultation template, with patients and practitioners,
which focuses consultations on quality of life themes.
l
Method: A nominal group was undertaken to develop a new consultation template for patients with
CVLUs based on the indings of earlier qualitative study phases.
l
Results: A user-friendly two-sided A4 template was designed to focus nurse-patient consultations on
the quality of life challenges posed by CVLUs.
l
Conclusion: CVLUs impact negatively on the quality of life of the patient but this receives inadequate
attention during current consultations.This new template will help to ensure that key concerns are
effectively raised, explored and addressed during each consultation.
l
Declaration of interest: The NHS West Midlands Strategic Health Authority funded this study.The
authors have no conlicts of interest to declare.
J. Green,
1
PhD, Lecturer;
R. Jester,
2
PhD, Professor;
R. McKinley,
3
PhD,
Professor of Education in
General Practice;
A. Pooler,
1
PhD, Lecturer;
S. Mason,
4
Clinical Lead
Tissue Viability;
S. Redsell,
5
Professor of
Public Health;
1 School of Nursing and
Midwifery, Keele
University, Staffordshire,
ST4 6QG
2 Faculty of Health and
Social Care, London
South Bank University,
London, SE1 0AA.
3 Keele University
Medical School,
Staffordshire, ST5 5BG.
4 Staffordshire and Stoke
on Trent Partnership
Trust, Bradwell Hospital,
Chesterton, Newcastle-
under-Lyme, ST5 7NJ
5 Faculty of Health, Social
Care & Education, Anglia
Ruskin University,
Cambridge
Email: j.green@keele.
ac.uk
Journal of Wound Care.Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 160.005.174.079 on March 13, 2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. . All rights reserved.