"Qualitative" Methods of Social Research in France:
Reconstructing the Actor, Deconstructing the Subject
Johannes Angermüller
Abstract: This contribution gives an overview of the numerous tendencies of open non-standardised
social research in France. For various reasons, the label "qualitative" seems to be less distinctive
than in the Anglo-Saxon world and Germany. While the interpretive-hermeneutic (verstehend) approa-
ches have recently come to play a certain role as a result of international reception, a strong
tradition that does not fit into the quantitative-qualitative divide has to be noted: discourse analysis
which I will label "quasi-qualitative". A comparison between the interpretive-hermeneutic tendencies of
qualitative sociology and the semiologically informed strands of discourse analysis reveals
fundamental differences as well as points of convergence.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. "Qualitative" Social Research:
The Discovery of the Human Actor
2.1 Ethnographic sociology
2.2 Idealtype based action sociology
2.3 Interpretive sociology
2.4 Techno-social network research
2.5 Biographical documentation
2.6 Computer-aided text analysis
2.7 Beyond the qualitative-quantitative divide
3. "Quasi-Qualitative" Research:
The Decentering of the Speaking Subject
in Discourse Analysis
3.1 Pioneers
3.2 Evolutions
3.3 Instruments
4. Comparing "Qualitative Sociology" and "Discourse Analysis"
4.1 Object of analysis: "discourse in situation" vs. "discursive formation"
4.2 Ontology of the empirical object: "intersubjective meaning" vs. "interdiscourse"
4.3 Methodology of knowledge production: "empathetic understanding" vs. "epistemological break"
4.4 Definition of the symbolic as "instrumental" vs. "material"
4.5 Objective of the research process: "thick description" vs. "rules of discursive formation"
5. Conclusion
© 2005 FQS http://www.qualitative-research.net/fqs/
Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research (ISSN 1438-5627)
Volume 6, No. 3, Art. 19
September 2005
Key words:
qualitative
sociology,
interpretive and
hermeneutic
methods,
ethnography,
discourse
analysis,
linguistics,
Foucault, Lacan,
Althusser,
pragmatics,
France
FORUM : QUALITATIVE
SOCIAL RESEARCH
SOZIALFORSCHUNG