92
Middle east Policy, Vol. XXi, No. 4, WiNter 2014
Iran under rouhanI: StIll alone In the World
Thomas Juneau
Dr. Juneau is an assistant professor with the Graduate School of Public
and International Affairs at the University of Ottawa. He is the author of
Squandered Opportunity: Neoclassical Realism and Iranian Foreign Policy
(Stanford University Press, forthcoming). Until July 2014, he was a strategic
analyst with the Department of National Defence, Government of Canada.
© 2014, The Author Middle East Policy © 2014, Middle East Policy Council
I
ran is alone in the world. Its acute
strategic loneliness is primarily the re-
sult of structural factors inherent in its
place in the regional and international
systems and is largely independent of the
actions of whoever governs the country. Its
international posture does not render co-
operation with other states impossible, nor
does it predetermine a condition of perma-
nent conlict with its neighbors. Strategic
loneliness, however, explains why Iran
has very limited common interests with its
neighbors and why cooperation is dificult
and costly to achieve. Tehran’s policies, as
a result, can worsen or improve the situa-
tion but cannot fundamentally change it.
Analyzing a state’s international
posture or position in the international
system is a necessary irst step that should
form the foundation of foreign-policy
analysis. After briely explaining what
strategic loneliness implies, this article
therefore will lay out the essential features
of Iran’s place in the regional and interna-
tional balances of power, which explain
the persistence of its strategic loneliness.
It then looks into how this posture shapes
the parameters of Iran’s most important
bilateral relations. Next, the article argues
that efforts launched in 2013 by President
Hassan Rouhani to solve the nuclear stand-
off between Iran, on the one hand, and the
United States and its allies and partners, on
the other, are unlikely to alter more than
marginally the Islamic Republic’s posture.
Even if Tehran and the international com-
munity reach a long-term solution, Iran’s
loneliness will endure.
THE MEANING OF STRATEGIC
LONELINESS
1
Whatever coniguration the regional
balances of power and interests take —
Iran’s power relative to its neighbors, the
presence of extraregional powers, the
speciic nature of the regimes in Tehran
and in neighboring capitals — Iran’s
strategic loneliness deprives it of space to
make gains from cooperation. Cooperation
obviously does not come easily for any
state in the anarchic international system.
But for Iran, the structure of the regional
balance makes it excessively dificult and
costly to engage in sustained cooperation
and to overcome its neighbors’ inherently
high levels of mistrust and suspicion. Such
an acute strategic loneliness explains both
continuities and ongoing challenges in