A polynomial approach for observer design in networked control
systems with unknown packet dropout rate.
I. Pe˜ narrocha, D. Dolz and R. Sanchis
Abstract— In this work, the observer design for systems oper-
ating over communication networks with previously unknown
packet dropout rate (PDR) is addressed. It is assumed that
the PDR is time-varying and that it can be estimated online
by means of the acknowledgement on new data arrival. The
observer gains depend on the estimated PDR and they are
designed minimizing the H∞ norm from disturbances and
measurement noises to estimation error over all the possible
PDRs. The observer gains are rational (including as a particular
case a polynomial) functions of the estimated PDR of the desired
order. An optimization over polynomials has been carried out
in order to find a solution for the proposed filter.
I. INTRODUCTION
In the last years many processes in industry are controlled
or supervised through sensors, actuators and controllers
connected to a shared network (wired or wireless). One of
the interesting control problems that arise in those scenarios
is the state estimation from measurements that are acquired
through a network. The main difficulties are the problems
of packet dropout, network induced delays, or intermittent
partial observations. Most of the proposals in the literature
can be classified in two generic groups: Kalman filter based
algorithms (e.g. [12], [10], [11]), in which the estimator
implements a modified Kalman filter to compute on line
the gains of an estimator, and off-line computed gains
strategies (e.g. [9], [13], [5]) in which the estimator gains
are previously computed and stored.
The use of a Kalman filter with irregular observations that
follow a Bernoulli distribution was firstly studied in depth
in [12], where the conditions for the existence of an estable
estimator were addressed, demonstrating the existence of a
critical value for the measurements arrival probability to get
a bounded filter when dealing with transmission of a packet
containing measurements from several sensors. The main
drawback is that the online computation of the gains requires
a high computer power, and, furthermore, the algorithm does
not give as a result a value of the bound of the estimation
error.
On the other hand, the off-line computed gains approaches
lead to a low computer cost algorithm and allow to obtain
in advance a bound of the estimation error. Previous works
(as [9], [13], [5], [6], [2]) propose a constant gain, or a set of
constant gains, that are not a function of the packet dropout
rate or the successful transmission probability. When these
are not known in advance, or are time varying, the resulting
observer is very conservative.
I. Pe˜ narrocha, D. Dolz and R. Sanchis are with Department of Industrial
System Engineering and Design, Universitat Jaume I of Castell´ o, Spain
{ipenarro,ddolz,rsanchis}@uji.es
In this work, the design of a rational gain-scheduled
observer is addressed for networks with packet dropout
whose successful transmission ratio is unknown in advance
and time-varying. The implemented observer gain at each
instant is a function of an estimation of the packet arrival
rate on the observer node, as a difference with other works.
This leads to a better estimator performance with a slight
increase in the computational cost. The design is addressed
assuring stochastic stability and H
∞
performance over the
disturbance, noises and time-varying and uncertain packet
dropout rate. Then, an LMI optimization problem is derived
from an optimization over polynomial constraints that tries
to minimize the state estimation error covariance for the
overall packet successful transmission rate. The degree of
the polynomials of the proposed Lyapunov function and the
observer gains is a tuning parameter that can be selected
as a compromise between the computational complexity of
the optimization problem to be solved, and the achievable
performance.
In order to overcome the optimization over polynomials,
the sum of squares (SOS) approach is used (see [1], [8], [3],
[7] and [4] or [8] for a tool that allows to implement these
methods).
The paper has the following structure: in Section II the
system is defined including the characteristics of the network
and the proposed state estimation algorithm. In Section III
the proposed solution for the polynomial observer design is
presented, including the necessary existing results about SOS
decomposition. Finally, in Section IV some examples show
the validity of the approach.
II. PROBLEM STATEMENT
A. System description
Let us assume a linear time invariant discrete time system
defined by equations
x
k
= Ax
k-1
+ Bu
k-1
+ B
w
w
k-1
, (1)
y
k
= Cx
k
+ v
k
, (2)
where x ∈ R
n
is the state, u ∈ R
nu
is the input, w ∈ R
nw
is
the state disturbance, y ∈ R
ny
are the measured outputs and
v
k
∈ R
ny
the measurement noise. Let us assume that the
output measurements are acquired through a network with
packet dropout, and let us define the binary variable called
availability factor of new data as
α
k
=
0, if y
k
is not received,
1, if y
k
is received.
(3)
52nd IEEE Conference on Decision and Control
December 10-13, 2013. Florence, Italy
978-1-4673-5716-6/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE 5933