CSIRO PUBLISHING
Marine and Freshwater Research, 2008, 59, 1048–1060 www.publish.csiro.au/journals/mfr
Selenium bioaccumulation and biomagnification
in Lake Wallace, New South Wales, Australia
J. F. Jasonsmith
A,C
, W. Maher
A,D
, A. C. Roach
B
and F. Krikowa
A
A
Institute for Applied Ecology, University of Canberra, Belconnen, ACT 2601, Australia.
B
Centre for Ecotoxicology, New South Wales Department of Environment and Climate Change,
Lidcombe, NSW 1825, Australia.
C
Current address: Earth and Marine Sciences, Australian National University,
Acton, ACT 0200, Australia.
D
Corresponding author. Email: bill.maher@canberra.edu.au
Abstract. Selenium concentrations were measured in water, sediments and organisms inhabiting a freshwater coal power
station cooling reservoir. Se concentrations found were: water, 1.9 ± 2 μgL
−1
; sediment, 7 ± 1 μgg
−1
; phytoplankton,
3.4 μgg
−1
; zooplankton, 5.3 μgg
−1
; epiphytic algae, 1.3 ± 0.2 μgg
−1
; benthic algae, 8 ± 2 μgg
−1
; macrophyte leaves,
2.7–2.8 μgg
−1
; macrophyte roots, 0.5–6.5 μgg
−1
; detritus, 10 μgg
−1
; Oligochaeta, 11 μgg
−1
; Corbiculidae, 1.1 μgg
−1
;
Insects, 3.7–8.3 μgg
−1
; Gastropoda, 3.2 μgg
−1
; Crustacea, 3.1–6 μgg
−1
; whole fish, 2.2–13 μgg
−1
; and fish liver, 134–
314 μgg
−1
. Bioconcentration factors were similar to those found in aquatic ecosystems with comparable Se concentrations
in the water column.A food web was constructed with four main food chains (phytoplankton, epiphytic algae, benthic algae
and sediment/detrital), with fish fed from multiple pathways. Biomagnification only occurs along food chains for flathead
gudgeons and rainbow trout. Se concentrations in food sources were above the 3 μgg
−1
dietary Se level considered to
induce teratogenesis in fish spawning. Flathead gudgeons were found to be suffering teratogenesis and rainbow trout
showed no evidence of teratogenesis.
Additional keyword: ecotoxicology.
Introduction
The ability of selenium (Se) to act as a toxicant was first noted in
the 1930s, when seleniferous soils were linked to fatalities in cat-
tle and horses (Seiler 1998). With the discovery in the 1950s that
Se also had nutritional benefits, the perception of Se as a toxicant
slowly faded from view (Milne 1998). The issue of Se toxicity
arose again in the late 1970s, when 12 of 16 fish species in a
coal power plant cooling basin – Belews Lake, North Carolina,
USA – disappeared. Se was found to be the sole cause of the fish
kills (Lemly 1985; Skorupa 1998). Extensive studies of Se bioac-
cumulation, biomagnification and toxicity have been undertaken
on freshwater ecosystems in the USA, with additional stud-
ies occurring in Sweden and the UK (Lemly 1999b; Hamilton
2004). In Australia, research on Se bioaccumulation and bio-
magnification in aquatic ecosystems has been confined mostly
to marine systems (Maher and Batley 1990; Peters et al. 1999a,
1999b; Kirby et al. 2001a, 2001b; Barwick and Maher 2003).
Few studies have been undertaken on freshwater ecosystems in
an Australian setting.
Se biomagnifies through food chains in aquatic ecosys-
tems receiving elevated Se inputs (Lemly 1993; Barwick and
Maher 2003). Where remediation has been carried out to lower
Se concentrations in water, aquatic flora and fauna continue
to contain high Se concentrations 10–20 years after remedia-
tion (Lemly 1997a). Se concentrations in food sources above
2–3 μgg
−1
dry mass are considered to induce teratogenesis in
fish spawning and deformities in fish larvae (Lemly 1993; Can-
ton andVan Derveer 1997). Organisms at lower trophic levels,
such as phytoplankton and invertebrates, can accumulate high Se
concentrations (100 μgg
−1
) without exhibiting any observable
effects (Foe and Knight 1986; Lemly 1993). However, consump-
tion of organisms containing Se at these levels is certain to affect
predators. Food chain studies help to understand pathways of
exposure, giving insights into how Se moves through aquatic
ecosystems, and allows identification of vulnerable components
of the ecosystem.
Coal-power stations currently supply 49% ofAustralia’s elec-
tricity, with energy demand projected to increase to 57% by
2040 (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2006; Saddler et al. 2007).
Cooling basins and ash dams are widely used in the manage-
ment of selenifierous wastes from coal-fired power stations.
These wastes are known to produce Se concentrations that can
be threatening to the health of some aquatic ecosystems. The
growing demand for energy increases the likelihood that Se
may enter the environment via cooling basins and ash dams.
As such, regulatory authorities need a better understanding
of the environmental significance of Se in potential receiv-
ing waters. This study was undertaken in part to meet these
research requirements in one such reservoir, Lake Wallace,
New South Wales.
© CSIRO 2008 10.1071/MF08197 1323-1650/08/121048