Book
Review
Edited by
Marjorie Keys
Disability and Child Sexual Abuse: Lessons from Survivors’
Narratives for Effective Protection, Prevention and Treatment
by M. Higgins and J. Swain, Jessica Kingsley Publishers, London,
2009. 256pp. ISBN 978-1-84310-563-3 (Pbk), £22.99
This book does not make easy reading. The authors themselves
note that it ‘may be a difficult book to read, and was certainly a
difficult book to write’ (p. 216). It is based around the accounts of
seven disabled adults who were sexually abused in childhood. The
shared themes in their narratives are carefully considered from
the perspective of the social model of disability. Through this
approach, the book examines how society places disabled children
in situations of unacceptable risk and makes it more difficult for
them to tell their stories and to be kept safe. The increased risk of
abuse faced by disabled children is now widely accepted, if poorly
understood. We have known for more than a decade that disabled
children are three to four times more likely to be abused (Sullivan
and Knutson, 1998, 2000). We have no right to be surprised or
shocked any more.
Martina Higgins and John Swain look at what makes for
abusive and non-abusive societies and consider the impact of
prejudice and discrimination on both risk and identity. A chapter
on organisational abuse shows how easy it is for abusive environ-
ments and practices to evolve.
The absence of any stories from people with learning disabili-
ties is a concerning omission, both because this is the most
common childhood impairment and because learning disabled
children are known to be particularly vulnerable to abuse. The
authors report significant efforts to engage learning disabled
adults, but without success. At least four of the seven survivors
were over 40 at the time of interview, and the experiences of
disabled children growing up in Britain today are in many ways
very different. This is not to suggest that prejudice, oppression and
disadvantage have disappeared, but long-term shifts in service
provision mean that segregated educational provision and the
institutionalisation of children are significantly less common.
Finally, there is no mention of recent changes designed to enable
vulnerable and intimidated witnesses to give their best evidence in
the criminal justice system.
This book places powerful individual narratives firmly at its
centre, which gives it significant strength and credibility. One of
the survivors gives his own perspective on the links between
disability and abuse: ‘I think it’s like having a double whammy;
you know, you’re hit once with your disability . . . then to get that
on top, you’re being hit twice’ (p. 72).
If we are to achieve the authors’ hope of creating ‘a society
in which the double whammy is part of the history of man’s
‘The increased risk
of abuse faced by
disabled children is
now widely accepted,
if poorly understood’
‘Significant efforts to
engage learning
disabled adults, but
without success’
‘This book places
powerful individual
narratives firmly atits
centre’
Child Abuse Review Vol. 21: 70–71 (2012)
Published online 29 September 2010 in Wiley Online Library
(wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI: 10.1002/car.1144
Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.