VIEWPOINT
IMMUNOLOGY TODAY
0167-5699/99/$ – see front matter © 1999 Elsevier Science. All rights reserved.
258 Vol.20 No.6
JUNE 1999
PII: S0167-5699(99)01471-1
cells from human immuno-
deficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)-
infected individuals are particu-
larly susceptible to cell death.
This occurs when cells are cultured without
mitogenic stimuli, but is markedly increased
after stimulation through the T-cell receptor
(TCR). A number of explanations have been
proposed to account for these phenomena,
including interactions between virus/viral
proteins and TCR/CD4 molecules, lack of
appropriate costimulary signals and dysregu-
lation of death regulatory proteins (such as
Bcl2 and CD95)
1–7
.
Apoptotic and necrotic
mechanisms of cell death coexist in HIV infection
It is commonly believed that cell death occurs from apoptosis, but in
reality there are multiple pathways leading to cell death in T cells
from HIV-1-infected individuals, and a substantial proportion of
T-cell mortality does not appear to occur via classical apoptosis.
Apoptotic cells are certainly observed after culture of T cells in the
absence of interleukin-2 (IL-2), due to growth factor withdrawal or
CD95–CD95 ligand (CD95L) interactions
3–5
. Nevertheless, mitogeni-
cally stimulated cells do not appear to die by this mechanism
8–11
. In
this article we describe a novel mechanism of activation-induced cell
death, that has many features of necrosis
8–11
, a phenomenon referred
to as activation-associated necrosis (AAN).
Activation-associated necrosis
When CD4
+
and CD8
+
T cells from HIV-1-infected patients are stimu-
lated in vitro with phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) or anti-CD3 mono-
clonal antibody (mAb), there is an early wave of apoptotic death that
occurs within the first 24 h. Later, between 48 and 72 h of culture,
further cells die
8–11
, but the cell loss can be attributed to an impaired
ability of T cells from HIV-1 infected patients to synthesize nu-
cleotides through the de novo pathway
10,11
. It appears that the resul-
tant ATP depletion and associated inability to synthesize new protein
or complete the cell cycle, leads eventually to necrotic cell death
10,11
Un-
like activation-induced cell death (AICD), which is mediated through
the CD95–CD95L pathway, cells destined to die via AAN show an
initial upregulation of CD25 and major histocompatibility complex
(MHC) class II, and commence synthesizing DNA (as measured by
bromodeoxyuridine uptake) but die before completing the cell cycle
8,9
.
When studied by light- and electron mi-
croscopy, apoptotic features such as chromatin
condensation or membrane flocculation are
absent. Rather, the cells display clear features
of necrosis, including membrane leakage and
diffused necrotic nuclei (Fig. 1). The percent-
age of cells with fragmented DNA (5%,
measured by the TUNEL assay) is the same as
seen in cultures from HIV-1
-
controls. How-
ever, all T cells from HIV-1
+
individuals, retain
the capacity to undergo apoptosis within 24 h
of treatment with apoptosis-inducing agents
such as okadaic acid
11
(Fig. 1d).
The process of AAN is intrinsic to T cells
from infected individuals and cannot be trans-
ferred from cell to cell in short-term cultures.
Thus, T cells from HIV
-
individuals prolifer-
ate normally when cocultured with dysfunctional cells from an HIV-1
+
patient
8
. The degree of cell death by AAN is variable, from 10 to 95%,
and, although the percentage of cells dying by AAN correlates weakly
with disease stage, can be detected in individuals with well-preserved
CD4 counts
9
. Furthermore, we found that in a cohort of 435 HIV-1-
infected patients high levels of AAN could predict AIDS and long-term
risk of death independently of the CD4 counts (M. Bofill, unpublished).
Although the CD8
+
CD45R0
+
population is the most sensitive to
AAN, all T-cell subsets, including CD4
+
CD45RA
+
naive cells, are sus-
ceptible
9
. We have found that entry into AAN cannot be reversed or
prevented by supplementing cultures with lymphokines or fibroblast-
derived factors that prevent spontaneous apoptosis, or by addition of
neutralizing antibodies to tumor necrosis factors or (TNF- or -)
or interferon (IFN-). Furthermore, neither blocking of CD95–CD95L
interactions nor the use of the caspase inhibitor ZVAD could prevent
cell death, confirming that AAN is not an apoptotic process
11
.
Impaired nucleotide metabolism and defective
proliferation in HIV-1 infection
The ability to synthesize purine and pyrimidine ribonucleotides de
novo is essential to all dividing cells, particularly those of the immune
system (Fig. 2). Just how essential intact de novo synthetic routes of
ribonucleotide formation are for proliferation in PHA-stimulated T
cells from healthy individuals has been demonstrated using inhibitors
of both purine and pyrimidine biosynthesis
12
. Thus, T cells cultured in
the presence of azaserine fail to proliferate in response to 72 h stimu-
lation with PHA, compared with uninhibited control cultures. The
inhibition is associated with the failure of ATP, GTP, UTP, CTP and
Novel mechanism for the impairment of
cell proliferation in HIV-1 infection
Margarita Bofill, Nicola J. Borthwick and H. Anne Simmonds
The synthesis of ribonucleotides is
essential to cell proliferation. Defects
in the relevant metabolic pathways
have been demonstrated in stimulated
T cells from AIDS patients and are
associated with lymphocyte necrotic
death. Here, Margarita Bofill and
colleagues discuss the possibility that
an impaired ribonucleotide
metabolism might be common to all
rapidly dividing cells and thus
contribute to other recognized
symptoms of HIV-1 infection.
T