A Combination of Quickest Detection with Oracle
Approximating Shrinkage Estimation and Its
Application to Spectrum Sensing in Cognitive Radio
Feng Lin, Zhen Hu, Robert C. Qiu
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering,
Center for Manufacturing Research,
Tennessee Tech University, Cookeville, TN, USA
Email: fenglin@ieee.org, zhu@tntech.edu, rqiu@tntech.edu
Michael C. Wicks
Sensor Systems Division,
University of Dayton Research Institute,
Dayton, OH, USA
Email: Michael.Wicks@udri.udayton.edu
Abstract—Spectrum sensing is a fundamental problem in cog-
nitive radio. How to sense the presence of primary user promptly
in order to avoid the unexpected interference is a key issue to the
system. The motivation of our work is to detect the primary user
signal using small size data in short time. In this paper, a quickest
detection based approach is proposed for spectrum sensing. This
approach employs covariance matrix estimation instead of sample
covariance matrix as the first step, then the core idea of sequential
detection or quickest detection is borrowed and utilized here
to improve the performance of traditional eigenvalue based
MME and AGM detectors. The main advantage of the proposed
approach is that it requires short data to detect quickly and it
works at lower SNR environments than some traditional methods.
A performance comparison between the proposed approach and
other traditional methods is provided, by the simulation on
captured digital TV (DTV) signal. The simulation results show
this proposed approach exhibits performance improvement while
the threshold keeps robust.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Spectrum sensing is the key component for cognitive radio
which is the next generation wireless communication system.
Spectrum sensing tries to find the spectrum hole available for
the unlicensed cognitive radio. Based on the results of spec-
trum sensing, cognitive radio can perform dynamic spectrum
access to make the spectrum utilization efficient.
For traditional sample covariance matrix based spec-
trum sensing methods, e.g., maximum-minimum eigenvalue
(MME) [1], arithmetic-to-geometric mean (AGM) [2], func-
tion of matrix detection (FMD) [3], [4], and so on, sample
covariance matrix based on large-size sensed data is used to
derive detection statistics. However, due to the short time dura-
tion of spectrum hole, the accurate and quick spectrum sensing
is the prerequisite of high-performance cognitive radio. If we
can shorten the time needed for spectrum sensing, more time
can be exploited and allocated for the reaction of cognitive
engine and dynamic spectrum access. The straightforward
challenge for quick spectrum sensing is how to guarantee the
detection performance of spectrum sensing using small-size
sensed data. This paper tries to address this issue and give the
potential solution to the quickest spectrum sensing in the low
SNR situation.
From the statistical point of view, the sample covariance
matrix is the maximum likelihood estimation of true covari-
ance matrix when sample size goes to infinity. However, if
sample size is small or the dimension of samples is in the
same order of sample size, the sample covariance matrix
can behave very badly, which cannot describe the accurate
statistical relationship within each sample.
Quickest detection [5] tries to detect the change of two
different random processes with the shortest delay. If the
change happens at the beginning of spectrum sensing, the goal
of quickest detection is similar to that of sequential detection.
The advantage of this paper is threefold:
• The proposed method can detect the PU signal quickly
without knowing the statistical distributions of PU signal
or noise.
• Given the number of data samples, the proposed method
works at lower SNR environment compared with some
other traditional approaches.
• The detection threshold of the proposed quickest spec-
trum sensing is invariant to the SNR and sample size.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section II
gives the background knowledge of spectrum sensing together
with the well-studied spectrum sensing methods. In section III,
the quickest spectrum sensing with small-size sensed data are
presented. Simulation results and performance evaluations are
given in section IV followed by some remarks in section V.
II. SYSTEM MODEL AND PRIOR SOLUTIONS
A. Binary Hypothesis
In a secondary network, we consider each secondary user
(SU) with one receive antenna to detect one primary user
(PU) signal based on its own observation. Let x(t) be the
continuous-time received signal after unknown channel. Let
T
s
be the sampling period, the received signal sample is
x [n] = x (nT
s
). There are two hypotheses to detect PU
signal’s existence, H
0
, only noise (no PU signal) exists; and
H
1
, both PU signal and noise exist. The received signal
samples under the two hypotheses are given respectively as
978-1-4673-3/12/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE 978-1-4673-3/12/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE