Investigation of Complex Iron Surface Catalytic Chemistry
Using the ReaxFF Reactive Force Field Method
CHENYU ZOU
1,2
and ADRI VAN DUIN
1
1.—Department of Mechanical Engineering, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA.
2.—e-mail: cvz5048@psu.edu
To demonstrate the feasibility of classical reactive dynamics for studying
complex surface chemistry, we performed a series of five reactive molecular
dynamics simulations addressing the carbon monoxide methanation and the
hydrocarbon chain initiation using the ReaxFF reactive force field method. We
found that the catalytic surface hydrogenation initiates from the undissoci-
ated CO molecules absorbed on the surface of the catalyst as described in
the oxygenate mechanism. This process leads to the generation of surface
absorbed CH
X
– groups, which initiates the synthesis of methane and the
hydrocarbon chain growth. Direct hydrogenation of the surface carbide was
not observed in the simulation. Coordination analysis of the carbon atoms in
the system provides possible explanations in that the surface carbon atoms are
further stabilized by the surface deformation of the iron catalyst at elevated
temperatures. Results from the simulations also indicated that the surface
CH– could dissociate into surface carbon atoms or be further hydrogenated
into CH
2
– radicals, which is an important intermediate species in the syn-
thesis of methane as well as the chain initiation. Results from the C–C
coupling simulation suggested the preference of coupling between CH– and
CH
2
– groups, which agrees with the alkenyl scheme of the carbene mecha-
nism. The overall results agree with the available experimental observations
and quantum mechanics (QM) study. Furthermore, these simulations indicate
the possible cooperation among different mechanisms and prove the service-
ability of the ReaxFF method for studying the complex heterogeneous cata-
lytic system. These simulations have also allowed us to evaluate the accuracy
of the current ReaxFF Fe/C/O/H description, providing crucial information
regarding areas where further improvement is required.
INTRODUCTION
Fischer–Tropsch (FT) synthesis
1
is an important
industrial process that converts a mixture of
hydrogen and carbon monoxide into varieties of
hydrocarbons. Its effectiveness of producing sulfur-
free fuels as well as organic chemicals of industrial
importance has attracted the attention of the
petroleum industry. Although widely used for
nearly a century,
2
it suffers from lacking a detailed
and precise reaction mechanism. Experimental
observations demonstrate that the process has a
strong dependence upon the choice of the catalysts
in terms of the product selectivity.
3,4
Iron-based
catalysts regenerate H
2
from H
2
O through a water–
gas–shift (WGS) reaction and hence allow the use of
feed gas with low H
2
content. In the meantime, iron
favors oxygenated hydrocarbons and suffers from
the accumulation of surface carbide, which intends
to deactivate the catalysts. In contrast, nickel-based
catalysts avoid the formation of inactive surface
carbon species but suffer from relatively high price
and high methane selectivity.
3
The complexity of the reaction mechanism has led
to a larger number of experimental measure-
ments
5–15
identifying possible reaction intermedi-
ates and chemical kinetics modeling.
16–20
Key
observations concerning the methanation process
from early experimental studies confirmed that
methylidyne (CH–), methylene (CH
2
–), and methyl
(CH
3
–) groups are all intermediates during a
JOM, Vol. 64, No. 12, 2012
DOI: 10.1007/s11837-012-0463-5
© 2012 TMS
1426 (Published online October 16, 2012)