Ecological Entomology (2011), 36, 309–317 DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2311.2011.01274.x
Wolbachia-induced feminisation newly found in Eurema
hecabe, a sibling species of Eurema mandarina
(Lepidoptera: Pieridae)
SATOKO NARITA,
1
DAISUKE KAGEYAMA,
1
MASATO HIROKI,
2
TAKESHI SANPEI,
2
SAORI HASHIMOTO,
2
TAKEHIKO
KAMITOH
2
and Y O S H I O M I K A T O
2∗
1
Insect-Microbe Research Unit, National Institute of
Agrobiological Sciences (NIAS), Ibaraki, Japan and
2
Department of Life Science, International Christian University, Tokyo, Japan
Abstract. 1. Complete feminisation of genetic males into functional females, a
unique case among insects, is known in Eurema mandarina (former Eurema hecabe
Y type) that are infected with two strains of Wolbachia, w CI
Em
and w Fem
Em
.
2. Here, we newly found that a proportion of wild-caught E. hecabe (former
E. hecabe B type) produced only female offspring. Cytogenetic observations indicated
that individuals of E. hecabe displaying the all-female trait were genetically male (i.e.
feminisation).
3. Multilocus sequence typing analyses demonstrated that the feminised individuals
of E. hecabe were infected with two Wolbachia strains, w CI
Eh
and w Fem
Eh
, that were
indistinguishable from w CI
Em
and w Fem
Em
, respectively.
4. Even identical strains of Wolbachia can be regulated differently depending on
the host genetic background. Therefore, we compared the infection densities and
vertical transmission efficiencies of Wolbachia between feminised E. mandarina and
E. hecabe, but detected no significant differences in these traits.
5. The possible routes by which the two Wolbachia strains have transferred between
E. mandarina and E. hecabe are discussed.
Key words. Eurema hecabe, Eurema mandarina, feminisation, multilocus sequence
typing, sibling species, Wolbachia.
Introduction
It was previously considered that, in Japan, the butterfly
Eurema hecabe L. (Lepidoptera: Pieridae) has two biotypes,
yellow type (Y type) and brown type (B type), that inhabit
temperate regions and subtropical regions, respectively (Kato,
1999, 2000a). The two biotypes differ in their expression of
polyphenism in response to the photoperiod and temperature
(Kato & Handa, 1992), host plants (Kato et al., 1992),
coloration of the wing fringe (Kato, 1999), allelic frequencies
of allozymes (Nomura & Kato, 1993), and mate choice by
females (Kobayashi et al., 2001; Kato, 2000c). Moreover,
it was recently shown that the nucleotide sequences of a
Correspondence: Satoko Narita, Insect-Microbe Research Unit,
National Institute of Agrobiological Sciences (NIAS), 1-2 Owashi,
Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8634, Japan. E-mail: naritas@affrc.go.jp
∗
Current address: Laboratory of Biodiversity Science, Graduate
School, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
nuclear gene, Tpi, are distinct between the two biotypes (Narita
et al., 2006). These data consistently and strongly suggest
that the Y type and B type constitute two closely related,
but distinct, biological species, and have led us to revise the
taxonomic statuses of these two biotypes. At present, E. hecabe
has been assigned as the former E. hecabe B type while
Eurema mandarina de l’Orza has been assigned as the former
E. hecabe Y type (Kato & Yata, 2005; Shirozu, 2006).
Eurema hecabe (former E. hecabe B type) mainly inhab-
its the southwestern islands of Japan while E. mandarina
mainly inhabits the mainland of Japan. However, E. mandarina
and E. hecabe sympatrically inhabit Okinawa Island, one
of the southwestern islands, although they feed on differ-
ent host plants (Kato, 2000b; Kato & Yata, 2005) and
are behaviourally and reproductively isolated (Kato, 2000c;
Kobayashi et al., 2001).
Previous studies have shown that E. hecabe and
E. mandarina are infected with bacteria belonging to the
© 2011 The Authors
Ecological Entomology © 2011 The Royal Entomological Society 309