vol. 35 • no. 3
GIFTED CHILD TODAY
COLUMNS
The Stress of Black Male Achievement
Ten Nonnegotiables
Malik S. Henfield, PhD'
Abstract: Oftentimes, when the subject of Black students'
talent maximization in gifted and advanced courses and
programs is broached, students are treated as a monolithic
entity. In fact, tbere is considerable evidence to suggest
tbat unsuccessful achievement of academic excellence
may be more troublesome for males than females at
many points along the educational pipeline (Ford,
2010; Grantharn, 2004a). School counselors, trained to
understand the intended and unintended consequences
of ignoring the itnportance of race and gender are well
equipped to assist in the battle to increase the academic
performance of talented Black males and—by extension—
aid in ameliorating the achievement gap between the best
and brightest Black students. The purpose of this column
is to provide a brief introduction of the cumulative risks
associated with being Black and male in educational
settings as well as a discussion of how these risks are
associated with mental health and academic performance.
The column will conclude witb a discussion of implications
for scbool counselors.
Keywords: gifted and talented, stress. Black males,
achievement
Multicultural Issues
T
oo few school counselors have received formal training
to work with and understand the experiences and
needs of gifted students (Peterson & Morris, 2010);
even fewer get training to counsel and guide gifted Black
students. As a professional school counselor, I decided to take
a different route to actively seek such training. I saw and still
see so tnany gifted students, especially Black males, failing to
achieve to their potential. Serving as leaders and advocates,
professional school counselors are in an ideal position to
support gifted students. In addition to supporting students'
academic and career needs, they are also prepared to nieet the
social-emotional and affective needs of gifted students from
all backgrounds. To be effective with Black males, however,
specific information must be understood first.
For quite some time, there has been a great deal of attention
given to the persistent disconnect between Black students and
high academic achievement. Specifically, an overwhelming
body of literature has been published highlighting the
difficulties Black students' experience in K-12 educational
environments in comparison with their White peers (Ford,
Grantham, & Whiting, 2008; National Center for Education
Statistics, 2003). Most often referred to as the achievement gap
(Barton & Coley, 2009; Ferguson, 2003), the conundrum can
best be described as nothing less than the top educational
crisis of our time—with no significant changes in sight. Indeed,
numerous policies have been created to address the issue, yet
the problem persists in urban, suburban, and rural contexts
alike.
Oftentimes, when the subject of Black students' talent
maximization in gifted and advanced courses and programs
is broached, students are treated as a monolithic entity. There
is considerable evidence that unsuccessful achievement of
academic excellence may be more troublesome for males than
females at many points along the educational pipeline (Ford,
2010; Grantham, 2004a, 2004b; Toldson, 2008). It is also quite
clear that when issues related to Black students, even those
formally identified as gifted, are introduced in popular and
scholarly literature, it typically focuses on race without taking
Black males' conceptions of masculinity (Majors & Billson,
1992) into much consideration. As a result, when constructing
interventions to disrupt the unfortunate academic trends as
related to Black males, masculinity is sacrificed for a narrow
focus on race; doing so fails to take into consideration the
cumulative risks associated with being Black and male, as
opposed to one or the other, and the issues the dual identities
represent for them in academic settings.
School counselors, trained to understand the intended and
unintended consequences of ignoring the importance of
race and gender are well equipped to assist in the battle to
increase the academic performance of talented Black males.
By extension, aiding in ameliorating the achievement gap
between capable Black students may also assist in closing the
ovei-all achievement gap between Black and White students
(Ford, 2011; Plucker, Burroughs, & Song, 2010). As such, the
DOI: 10.1177/1076217512445999. From 'The University of Iowa. Address correspondence to: Malik S. Henfield, PhD, N352 Lindquist Center, Department of Rehabilitation and Counselor
Education, College of Education, The University of Iowa, Iowa City, lA 52242; email: malik-henfield@uiowa.edu.
For reprints and permissions queries, please visit SAGE's Web site at http://www.sagepub.com/iournalsPermission.nav.
Copyright © 2012 The Author(s)
215