Analyzing Event-Related Brain Dynamics in
Continuous Compensatory Tracking Tasks
Ruey-Song Huang
1,2
, Tzyy-Ping Jung
2
and Scott Makeig
2
1
Department of Cognitive Science, University of California, San Diego, USA
2
Swartz Center for Computational Neuroscience, Institute for Neural Computation, University of California, San Diego, USA
Abstract-- The dynamics of electroencephalographic (EEG)
activity in continuous compensatory tracking tasks were
analyzed by independent component analysis (ICA) and
time-frequency techniques. In one-hour sessions, 72-channel
EEG was recorded while a healthy volunteer attempted to use
a trackball to keep a drifting disc in a bulls-eye in the center of
screen. Disc trajectory was converted into a moving measure
of disc error. Local minima (perigees) indicated moments
when the disc started to drift away from the center. Subject
performance was indexed by root mean square disc error in a
20s epoch centered on each perigee, high error generally
indicating drowsiness. Maximally independent EEG processes
and their equivalent dipole source locations were obtained
using the EEGLAB toolbox (http://sccn.ucsd.edu/eeglab).
Component activations were epoched in 5s time intervals time
locked to perigees. Following disk perigees during (drowsy)
periods of high disk error, significant spectral changes were
observed. One of the 70 independent components was located
in or near primary visual cortex. During periods of poor
(drowsy) performance, it had increased mean tonic
alpha/theta activity, with a further phasic alpha/theta increase
following perigees [1, 2]. At the same time, low alpha activity
of a second component located in or near cingulate gyrus
increased, and 10-30 Hz EEG activity of a third component in
the left somatomotor cortex increased briefly. The alpha
activity of the somatomotor component persisted through the
following distance maximum. These spatiotemporal
phenomena were consistently observed across three sessions
within subjects. Thus, event-related EEG brain dynamics can
be detected and modeled in a continuous behavioral task
without impulsive event onsets.
Index Terms -- EEG, ICA, ERSP, continuous task,
performance, brain dynamics, theta, alpha, beta.
I. INTRODUCTION
Sensory event-related potentials (ERP) index mean
electroencephalographic (EEG) activities following onsets
of visual or auditory stimuli. In many ERP paradigms,
participants respond to stimuli with discrete button presses.
ERPs are usually obtained by time-domain average of EEG
epochs precisely phase-locked to stimulus or to response
onsets. In real-life, many tasks require more or less
continuous efforts to maintain appropriate behavior, instead
of discrete (button) choice responses. During the course of
truly continuous performance paradigm, on the other hand
(e.g., in driving simulations), participants can receive
continuous visual and/or auditory stimuli as well as
continuous performance feedback. The ERP averaging
technique is limited to tasks with discrete stimulus events
and may require a silent baseline period preceding stimulus
onsets, making it of little use for assessing brain dynamics
in continuous performance tasks.
In this study, we applied event-related spectral
perturbation (ERSP) methods to study event-related brain
dynamics in a continuous compensatory tracking task (CTT)
during which participants attempted to use a trackball to
keep a randomly drifting disc in a bulls-eye on the center of
screen [3]. Independent component analysis (ICA) was
applied to continuous EEG data collected in each of the
1-hour CTT sessions. Maximally independent EEG
processes and their dipole source locations were obtained
by the EEGLAB toolbox (http://sccn.ucsd.edu/eeglab) [4].
During high-error periods, three clusters of independent
components exhibited significant spectral perturbations
following disc trajectory ‘perigees’ (moments when the
disc began to escape from the center). Within subjects, the
component activations and scalp topographies of these
clusters were stable across sessions. This study also
demonstrates that brain dynamics linked to changes in
human performance can be assessed on the sub-second time
scale in a continuous performance task.
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS
A. Participants and Tasks
Six right-handed adults (3 males, 3 females, mean age=
27.8, SD = 6.0) with normal or corrected to normal vision
volunteered to participate in this experiment. Informed
consent was obtained from all participants. Participants
arrived after lunch and sat on a cozy chair in the EEG booth
in which lighting was dim. Each subject participated a three
one-hour sessions of continuous visuospatial compensatory
tracking tasks in which they attempted to use a trackball to
keep a drifting (‘wind-blown’) disc in a bulls-eye as near as
possible to the center of screen (Fig. 1). Participants were
instructed to continue to perform the task as best as they
could even when they began to feel drowsy. No
intervention was made when participants occasionally fell
asleep and stopped responding; participants resumed task
performance themselves after non-responding periods. The
coordinates of the drifting disc and trackball activities were
recorded about 14 times per second while a synchronous
pulse marker train was sent to the EEG recording system.
Proceedings of the 2005 IEEE
Engineering in Medicine and Biology 27th Annual Conference
Shanghai, China, September 1-4, 2005
0-7803-8740-6/05/$20.00 ©2005 IEEE.