©2001 Blackwell Science, Inc.
VIEWPOINT
Degrading Landscapes: Lessons from Palliative Care
Linda J. Kristjanson* and Richard J. Hobbs†
*Faculty of Communications, Health and Science, Edith Cowan University,
Churchlands, Western Australia;
†
School of Environmental Science,
Murdoch University, Murdoch, Western Australia
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
Increasing interest is being shown in the concept
of ecosystem health as an integrative framework
for considering ecosystem and landscape manage-
ment (Rapport 1995a,b,c; Rapport et al. 1998;
Rapport & Whitford 1999). In doing this, oppor-
tunities arise to transfer concepts and approaches
from human health care to ecosystem and land-
scape management. In this paper, we explore
whether emerging health paradigms based on
palliative care have relevance in the sphere of
landscape management. In particular, can some
degrading landscapes be viewed in some cases as
being “terminally ill,” and if so, how can these
landscapes be managed and how can the human
communities dependent on these landscapes be
assisted?
To do this, we first explore the need for a
shift in emphasis in health care away from techno-
logical, reductionist approaches toward more ho-
listic approaches including palliative care. This in
turn necessitates a change in worldview that in-
corporates recognition of death as a natural pro-
cess. The principles that shape the modern world-
view developed 300 years ago, and although this
view has been greatly refined and modified in the
years since, it has retained much of its early vision.
The modern age is the Machine Age, comprising
the postindustrial and information technology
revolutions, where precision, speed, and accuracy
are the premier values. This mechanical para-
digm is simple, predictable, and above all, it has
worked (Rifkin 1989).
Modern health care, like almost every other
activity in contemporary society, reflects this
worldview. The mechanical approach to medicine
has dominated the health care profession for 200
years. This “modern” worldview has dominated
medical thinking but is increasingly challenged in
the wake of pressing global issues, such as the
Palliative care is the active total care of patients whose
disease is not responsive to curative treatment. This pa-
per presents a proposition that the principles of palliative
care may offer a useful conceptual map that helps pro-
mote understanding of the degradation of landscapes
and the decline of rural communities from an ecosystem
management perspective. Landscape reorganization by
humans for food and other production requires consid-
erable inputs of energy and effort. Current trends of
landscape degradation indicate that human endeavors
have resulted in the loss of functional landscapes with a
concurrent decline in ecosystem services. The argument
can be made that, in cases where ecosystem degrada-
tion is extensive, the landscape may be terminally ill and
in need of palliative care. The fundamental principles
and components of palliative care are described and
questions are posed regarding the extent to which pal-
liative care principles and components challenge and ex-
tend current land management philosophies and prac-
tices.
Address correspondence to: Linda J. Kristjanson, Professor,
School of Nursing & Public Health, Edith Cowan University,
Churchlands Campus, Pearson Street, Churchlands, Western
Australia 6018.