Coating of Nafion Membranes with Polyelectrolyte Multilayers to
Achieve High Monovalent/Divalent Cation Electrodialysis
Selectivities
Nicholas White,
†
Maria Misovich,
†
Andriy Yaroshchuk,
‡
and Merlin L. Bruening*
,†
†
Department of Chemistry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan 48824, United States
‡
ICREA and Department of Chemical Engineering, Polytechnic University of Catalonia, av. Diagonal 647, 08028 Barcelona, Spain
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Electrodialysis (ED) membranes typically exhibit modest
selectivities between monovalent and divalent ions. This paper reports a
dramatic enhancement of the monovalent/divalent cation selectivities of
Nafion 115 membranes through coating with multilayer poly(4-styrenesul-
fonate) (PSS)/protonated poly(allylamine) (PAH) films. Remarkably, K
+
/
Mg
2+
ED selectivities reach values >1000, and similar monovalent/divalent
cation selectivities occur with feed solutions containing K
+
and Ca
2+
. For
comparison, the corresponding K
+
/Mg
2+
selectivity of bare Nafion 115 is only
1.8 ± 0.1. However, with 0.01 M KNO
3
and 0.01 M Mg(NO
3
)
2
in the source
phase, as the applied current density increases from 1.27 to 2.54 mA cm
−2
, the K
+
/Mg
2+
selectivities of coated membranes
decrease from >1000 to 22. Water-splitting at strongly overlimiting current densities may lead to a local pH increase close to the
membrane surface and alter film permeability or allow passage of Mg(OH)
x
species to decrease selectivity. When the source
phase contains 0.1 M KNO
3
and 0.1 M Mg(NO
3
)
2
, the K
+
transference number approaches unity and the K
+
/Mg
2+
selectivity is
>20 000, presumably because the applied current is below the limiting value for K
+
and H
+
transport is negligible at this high K
+
concentration. The high selectivities of these membranes may enable electrodialysis applications such as purification of salts that
contain divalent or trivalent ions.
KEYWORDS: electrodialysis, layer-by-layer, polyelectrolyte, ion-exchange membranes, selectivity
1. INTRODUCTION
Electrodialysis (ED) is a membrane-based separation technique
for applications such as preconcentrating brines,
1
recovering
organic acids from waste-salt solutions,
2
organic acid
production,
3
treating wastewater effluent,
4
demineralizing
milk byproducts,
5
and desalting brackish water.
6,7
In
commercially viable configurations, alternating anion- and
cation-exchange membranes in flow-cells create parallel diluate
and concentrate streams to enable high throughput.
8
Under an
applied current or potential, cations leave the diluate compart-
ment through the cation-exchange membrane, whereas anions
leave in the opposite direction through the anion-exchange
membrane. Thus, ED effectively removes ions from feed
streams, but typical ion-exchange membranes exhibit low
selectivities among ions. Such selectivities are important when
employing ion-exchange membranes in some ED applications,
e.g., removal of SO
4
2−
from sea salt, or other functions such as
prevention of vanadium crossover in redox flow batteries.
9−12
Although variation of current density and concentration
polarization may provide some control over ion-transport
selectivity,
13
the development of ED for separating ions
requires ion-exchange membranes with high selectivities. Sata
and co-workers showed that polycation or polyanion coatings
on ion-exchange membranes enhance selectivity among cations
or anions, respectively.
14−16
Deposition of protonated poly-
ethylenimine (PEI) on cation-exchange membranes increases
monovalent/divalent cation selectivity, and control over the
hydrophobicity and cross-linking at the membrane surface leads
to Na
+
/Ca
2+
selectivities up to 7.
14
Additionally, increasing the
hydrophilicity of anion-exchange membranes with adsorbed
ethylene glycols increases SO
4
2−
/Cl
−
selectivities from <0.1 to
0.8.
17,18
Rakib and co-workers observed a Na
+
/Cr
3+
selectivity
of 10−20 using an electrodeposited PEI film on a Nafion
cation-exchange membrane.
19
Nevertheless, these selectivities
are relatively modest. In this study, we examine whether
adsorption of polyelectrolyte multilayers on ion-exchange
membranes can yield even higher selectivities.
With the development of alternating adsorption of
polycations and polyanions to form ultrathin coatings,
20
several
research groups began investigating whether polyelectrolyte
multilayers (PEMs) can serve as ultrathin membrane skins that
show high selectivity among cations or anions.
21−23
In many
cases, monovalent ions move through these membranes more
readily than multivalent ones, presumably because of enhanced
electrostatic and size-based exclusion of highly hydrated,
multiply charged ions. Although Michaels formed membranes
Received: December 18, 2014
Accepted: March 4, 2015
Research Article
www.acsami.org
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/am508945p
ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX