The role of the instructor in business
games: a comparison of face-to-face
and online instruction
Ana Beatriz Hernández, María Tatiana Gorjup and
Rosalía Cascón
This study analyses the role of the instructor in the e-learning
process fostered by a business game. To achieve this objective,
a comparative analysis was conducted with two groups of
students regarding their perceptions of the instructor’s role in a
business game. The first group was composed of 33 participants
and facilitated by an instructor in a face-to-face process. The
second group was composed of 23 participants and facilitated
by the same instructor online. Our results indicate that the
students’ assessment of the role of the instructor is clearly
different in both cases: the face-to-face group valued the rel-
evance of the instructor’s role in the learning process more
highly than the online group. Our findings also highlight the
importance of the instructor’s role in improving the students’
learning experience and suggest that extra efforts by online
instructors are needed to maximize the e-learning process
through business games in management training.
Introduction
A generic vision of e-learning involves different forms of learning supported by infor-
mation and communication technologies (ICTs) and the use of the Internet to enhance
knowledge and performance (McGill & Klobas, 2009). The spectacular development of
ICTs, and especially the Internet, has been changing teaching and learning processes
for some years now (Ma et al., 2000). This has led to more widespread access to
education by larger groups, new methods and mechanisms of study, rapid growth of
❒ Ana Beatriz Hernández, Lecturer, Department of Business Management, Rovira i Virgili University,
Avinguda Universitat, 1 (43204) Reus, Spain. Email: anabeatriz.hernandez@urv.cat. María Tatiana
Gorjup, Lecturer, Department of Business Management, Rovira i Virgili University,Avinguda Univer-
sitat, 1 (43204) Reus, Spain. Email: mariatatiana.gorjup@urv.cat. Rosalía Cascón, Lecturer, Department of
Business Management, Rovira i Virgili University,Avinguda Universitat, 1 (43204) Reus, Spain. Email:
rosalia.cascon@urv.cat
International Journal of Training and Development 14:3
ISSN 1360-3736
© 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
The role of the instructor in business games 169