Deadly Weapon–Related Open-Globe Injuries:
Outcome Assessment by the Ocular Trauma
Classification System
GU
¨
NGO
¨
R SOBACI, MD, F. MEHMET MUTLU, MD, ATILLA BAYER, MD,
SUAT KARAGU
¨
L, MD, AND EROL YILDIRIM, MD
●
PURPOSE: To describe mechanisms and injury charac-
teristics influencing visual outcomes in eyes with open-
globe injuries caused by deadly weapons and to apply the
classification system introduced by the Ocular Trauma
Classification Group.
●
METHODS: Two-hundred-twenty-eight eyes of 212
consecutive patients, who were mostly injured in military
confrontation, were analyzed. Mechanism and injury
characteristics were evaluated for predicting visual out-
come according to the recently studied classification
system as well as other variables pertinent to this specific
clinical setting of severe eye trauma. Final visual acuities
were defined as favorable (5/200 or better) or unfavor-
able (less than 5/200, including enucleation).
●
RESULTS: The mean age of patients was 23 years, and
the mean follow-up was 5.7 months. The predictors for
favorable visual outcome were type B, grade 1, zone I,
and relative afferent pupillary defect-negative injuries.
The predictors for unfavorable outcome were type A,
grade 5, zone III, and relative afferent pupillary defect-
positive injuries. Land mine and hand grenade injuries
had the worst outcome among causative agents. Prolifer-
ative vitreoretinopathy, comprising 30.4% of postopera-
tive failures, was the most common complication.
●
CONCLUSION: Deadly weapon–related open-globe in-
juries, especially those associated with land mines and
hand grenades, have devastating visual results. Evalua-
tion of trauma mechanism and injury characteristics
according to the Ocular Trauma Classification System
seems to predict visual outcomes in this series of severe
open-globe injuries. (Am J Ophthalmol 2000;129:
47–53. © 2000 by Elsevier Science Inc. All rights
reserved.)
O
CULAR TRAUMA CONSTITUTES ONE OF THE MOST
common causes of unilateral morbidity and blind-
ness in the world today. Despite huge advances in
vitreoretinal surgery in recent years, a dismal prognosis still
persists in certain injuries. Eye injuries resulting from
violence are increasing in both civilian and wartime
settings in recent years.
1–3
The heterogeneity of the inju-
ries in ocular trauma has made it difficult to interpret
results of clinical studies with respect to intervention and
prevention of blindness. Recently, a classification system
for standardized assessment of ocular trauma was intro-
duced.
4
If validated, this system, or a similar classification
system, would allow objective assessment for both clinical
prognosis and interventional studies.
We aimed to identify patient and injury characteristics
in deadly weapon-related eye injuries according to the
Ocular Trauma Classification System, as well as other
variables pertinent to this unusual type of severe eye
trauma, at a principal center for military medicine in
Turkey.
PATIENTS AND METHODS
WE CONDUCTED A RETROSPECTIVE REVIEW OF ALL PA-
tients presenting with open-globe injury to the Ophthal-
mology Department of Gu ¨lhane Military Medical
Academy and Medical School between March 1991 and
April 1997. We identified 228 eyes of 212 patients who
underwent surgical repair of open-globe injuries in our
institution. An open-globe injury was defined as a full-
thickness wound of the eyewall (through-and-through
injury of the sclera, cornea, or both).
4
The hospital
inpatient and outpatient records of these patients were
reviewed in detail with respect to prognostic variables
indicated by the Ocular Trauma Classification System
4
as
well as other variables of prognostic value in open-globe
injuries. The variables studied were type (mechanism) of
injury, grade (visual acuity at presentation) of injury, zone
(location and extent) of injury, presence or absence of
Accepted for publication June 29, 1999.
From the Department of Ophthalmology, Gu ¨lhane Military Medical
Academy and Medical School, Ankara, Turkey.
Reprint requests to Gu ¨ngo ¨r Sobaci, MD, GATA Go ¨z Klinigi, 06018
Etlik, Ankara, Turkey; fax: 90 312 321 7778; e-mail: gsobaci@gata.edu.tr
© 2000 BY ELSEVIER SCIENCE INC.ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. 0002-9394/00/$20.00 47
PII S0002-9394(99)00254-8