VOL. 15, NO. 1 n THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MANAGED CARE n 13
n CLINICAL n
© Managed Care &
Healthcare Communications, LLC
H
urricane Katrina has had profound and ongoing effects on
the health of inhabitants of the city of New Orleans, Louisi-
ana, and surrounding areas. Numerous reports on the imme-
diate health effects of Hurricane Katrina have focused on surveillance
of the following: mortality, injury, and illness
1,2
; mental health prob-
lems
3
; health services utilization
4,5
; disruption to the healthcare de-
livery system
4,6,7
; implications for patient care during disasters
8
; and
suggestions for health policy change.
9
Although the disaster literature
contains many studies on the immediate health effects of natural di-
sasters, few (including the Hurricane Katrina literature) have tracked
health outcomes during the long term or have been able to compare
health status before an event versus after an event.
10,11
Older adults
with a heavy burden of chronic conditions require effective care deliv-
ery systems
12
; however, few studies to date have focused on the health
effects following a major disruption to care delivery such as occurred
with Hurricane Katrina.
The first objective of this study was to document mortality associ-
ated with Hurricane Katrina in a defined population of older adults. The
second objective was to explore the relationship between prehurricane
health risk status and the effects of the hurricane on morbidity and
health service use in a population of continuously enrolled older persons
from a New Orleans–based Medicare Advantage plan.
METHODS
Peoples Health (PH) is a provider-owned managed care organization
(MCO) that served approximately 20% of all Medicare beneficiaries
65 years and older in 4 parishes around New Orleans before Hurricane
Katrina through its Medicare Advantage plan, with a provider network
of 7 independent practice associations representing 1101 participating
physicians (160 primary care physicians and 941 specialists). Peoples
Health remained operational throughout Hurricane Katrina, moving its
administrative operations from New Orleans to Baton Rouge, Louisi-
ana. Through December 2006, PH used mailings, their Web site, and
the news media to inform its members that all copayments and deduct-
ibles for out-of-area services would be
waived as required by the Centers for
Medicare & Medicaid Services.
13
The
information system of PH captures all
data on outpatient and office encoun-
In this issue
Take-away Points / p20
www.ajmc.com
Full text and PDF
Health of Medicare Advantage Plan Enrollees
at 1 Year After Hurricane Katrina
Lynda C. Burton, ScD; Elizabeth A. Skinner, MSW; Lori Uscher-Pines, PhD;
Richard Lieberman, BA; Bruce Leff, MD; Rebecca Clark, BA; Qilu Yu, PhD;
Klaus W. Lemke, PhD; and Jonathan P. Weiner, DrPH
Objective: To assess the effects of Hurricane Ka-
trina on mortality, morbidity, disease prevalence,
and service utilization during 1 year in a cohort
of 20,612 older adults who were living in New
Orleans, Louisiana, before the disaster and who
were enrolled in a managed care organization
(MCO).
Study Design: Observational study comparing
mortality, morbidity, and service use for 1 year
before and after Hurricane Katrina, augmented by
a stratified random sample of 303 enrollees who
participated in a telephone survey after Hurricane
Katrina.
Methods: Sources of data for health and service
use were MCO claims. Mortality was based on
reports to the MCO from the Centers for Medicare
& Medicaid Services; morbidity was measured
using adjusted clinical groups case-mix methods
derived from diagnoses in ambulatory and hospi-
tal claims data.
Results: Mortality in the year following Hurricane
Katrina was not significantly elevated (4.3% be-
fore vs 4.9% after the hurricane). However, overall
morbidity increased by 12.6% (P <.001) compared
with a 3.4% increase among a national sample of
Medicare managed care enrollees. Nonwhite sub-
jects from Orleans Parish experienced a morbidity
increase of 15.9% (P <.001). The prevalence of nu-
merous treated medical conditions increased, and
emergency department visits and hospitalizations
remained significantly elevated during the year.
Conclusions: The enormous health burden expe-
rienced by older individuals and the disruptions
in service utilization reveal the long-term effects
of Hurricane Katrina on this vulnerable popula-
tion. Although quick rebuilding of the provider
network may have attenuated more severe health
outcomes for this managed care population,
new policies must be introduced to deal with the
health consequences of a major disaster.
(Am J Manag Care. 2009;15(1):13-22)
For author information and disclosures,
see end of text.