Journal of Biomaterials and Nanobiotechnology, 2012, 3, 335-341
doi:10.4236/jbnb.2012.33031 Published Online July 2012 (http://www.SciRP.org/journal/jbnb)
335
Strontium and Silicon Co-Doped Apatite Coating:
Preparation and Function as Vehicles for Ion Delivery
Carl Lindahl
1,2
, Wei Xia
1,2*
, Jukka Lausmaa
2,3
, Per Borchardt
2,3
, Håkan Engqvist
1,2*
1
Division of Applied Material Science, Department of Engineering Sciences, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden;
2
BIOMATCELL
VINN Excellence Center of Biomaterials and Cell Therapy, Gothenburg, Sweden;
3
Department of Chemistry and Materials Tech-
nology, SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden, Boras, Sweden.
Email: {
*
wei.xia,
*
hakan.engqvist}@angstrom.uu.se
Received April 2
nd
, 2012; revised May 6
th
, 2012; accepted May 26
th
, 2012
ABSTRACT
New methods to improve the bone response to metallic implants are still emerging, ranging from surface modifications
of the metal to coatings and drug delivery. One further development of coatings on implants is to incorporate bioactive
ions in order to stimulate the bone response without the need of drug delivery. The aim of the current study is to prepare
apatite coatings containing Sr and Si using a solution method, for the purpose of further optimising the bone response to
metal implants. Titanium substrates were activated to induce the formation of coatings in modified PBS solutions.
Soaking in PBS solutions with different concentrations of strontium and silicate at 37˚C or 60˚C produced coatings with
different morphologies, thicknesses and compositions. Ion release experiments showed simultaneous release of Sr and
Si from the coatings both in PBS and Tris-HCl. Analysis of the results using the Korsmeyer-Peppas model indicate that
the release of ions from the coatings was a combination of Fickian diffusion and dissolution of the coatings. This study
shows that it is possible to coat Ti substrates with modified apatite with ion release functionality and thereby increase
the possibilities for a tailored bone response in vivo.
Keywords: Strontium; Silicon; Apatite Coating; Ion Delivery
1. Introduction
Hydroxyapatite (HA) is widely used as a coating to im-
prove the bone-bonding of permanent implants for bio-
medical applications such as hip prostheses [1,2]. By
improving the bond between the implant and bone the
risk of revision surgery can be reduced [3,4]. Previously,
HA prepared with a mineralization method has been co-
loaded with bisphosphonates and antibiotics, with the
purpose of promoting bone formation around the implant
site and reducing the risk of infections [5]. However, the
introduction of pharmaceutical agents significantly adds
to the complexity of implants, both from a manufacturing,
handling and regulatory point of view. Biologically active
ions could be used as alternative approach to overcome
some of these drawbacks. Studies have shown that ion
doped HA, i.e. hydroxyapatite containing foreign ions, is
a promising way to improve the cell proliferation and in
vivo bone tissue response without the addition of phar-
maceutical agents [6-8]. Compared to pure HA, these
modified HA have different solubility, crystallinity and
topography, all of which are factors that are expected to
influence the bone response around the implant [9].
Bone consists of cells, collagen fibers and hydroxya-
patite, the latter containing traces of Sr
2+
, Si
4+
and F
–
in
the HA-lattice [10,11]. Strontium has been shown to en-
hance the bone formation in vitro and in vivo [12], and
the incorporation of silicon into the apatite structure was
found to result in a biomaterial with improved osseo-
integration properties compared to pure hydroxyapatite
[6]. A silicon doped hydroxyapatite coating prepared
with a mineralization method on porous titanium sub-
strate has also been tested in vivo with promising results
[13]. The (in vivo) results showed that the bone in-
growth rate (BIR) was significantly higher for silicon-
doped HA (Si-HA) coating than for the pure HA [13]. In
view of these observations, a simultaneous delivery of
multiple ion species from an implant coating in vivo
could help to induce bone formation and also reduce
bone resorption. It could therefore be possible to com-
bine these effects by co-doping strontium and silicon into
the hydroxyapatite coatings. The preparation of co-doped
hydroxyapatite ceramics, mostly based on powder tech-
niques, has previously been reported [14-17]. Some work
has also been reported on preparation of Sr or Si con-
taining hydroxyapatite coatings by a mineralization me-
thod [7,18-20].
The aim of this work was to prepare apatite coatings
Copyright © 2012 SciRes. JBNB