1. Introduction
2. Tissue bioengineering and HTS
3. Recent models of normal
tissues
4. Recent models of cancerous
tissues
5. The challenge of angiogenesis
6. Assays and scalability of 3D
cultures
7. Conclusion
8. Expert opinion
Review
3D in vitro tissue models and their
potential for drug screening
Lauren Kimlin, Jareer Kassis & Victoria Virador
†
†
Bethesda, MD, USA
Introduction: The development of one standard, simplified in vitro three-
dimensional tissue model suitable to biological and pathological investiga-
tion and drug-discovery may not yet be feasible, but standardized models
for individual tissues or organs are a possibility. Tissue bioengineering, while
concerned with finding methods of restoring functionality in disease, is devel-
oping technology that can be miniaturized for high throughput screening
(HTS) of putative drugs. Through collaboration between biologists, physicists
and engineers, cell-based assays are expanding into the realm of tissue analy-
sis. Accordingly, three-dimensional (3D) micro-organoid systems will play an
increasing role in drug testing and therapeutics over the next decade. Never-
theless, important hurdles remain before these models are fully developed
for HTS.
Areas covered: We highlight advances in the field of tissue bioengineering
aimed at enhancing the success of drug candidates through pre-clinical opti-
mization. We discuss models that are most amenable to high throughput
screening with emphasis on detection platforms and data modeling.
Expert opinion: Modeling 3D tissues to mimic in-vivo architecture remains a
major challenge. As technology advances to provide novel methods of HTS
analysis, so do potential pitfalls associated with such models and methods.
We remain hopeful that integration of biofabrication with HTS will signifi-
cantly reduce attrition rates in drug development.
Keywords: 3D models, bioengineering, cell sheet stacking, cocultures, high throughput
screening, organoids, spheroids, tissue regeneration, tissue repair, vascularization
Expert Opin. Drug Discov. [Early Online]
1. Introduction
There is an abundance of convincing literature that tissue composition plays a key
role in signaling gene expression, differentiation and function [1,2]. Concordantly,
three-dimensional tissue cultures are a fast-growing method to investigate cell
biology [3]. Small molecules that show high efficacy against cells assayed as mono-
layers often do not reproduce their effectiveness in 3D cultures [4] thus providing
misleading toxicological and functional data [5,6]. Such observations strongly sug-
gest that screening methods utilizing 3D systems of cell culture are more instruc-
tive and predictive than 2D. Developing any high throughput system for drug
testing involves considering toxicity and efficacy, both measures required for drugs
moving from the lab to the clinic. As both toxicity and efficacy are sometimes tis-
sue- or organ- specific, in vitro tissue models can more accurately predict drug
dosage [7,8].
We intend to cover advances in tissue bioengineering that are or may be amena-
ble to HTS in the near future. Tissue bioengineering simulates native living tissues
using isolated cell cultures generally embedded in scaffolds - biocompatible net-
works of synthetic or natural polymers - which serve as extracellular matrix
(ECM) mimics to provide vital extracellular support [7]. Alternative grafts are scaf-
fold-free, self-assembly based methods that can be envisioned as catalysts in the
10.1517/17460441.2013.852181 © 2013 Informa UK, Ltd. ISSN 1746-0441, e-ISSN 1746-045X 1
All rights reserved: reproduction in whole or in part not permitted
Expert Opin. Drug Discov. Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by 69.140.33.169 on 10/22/13
For personal use only.