Plant and Soil 202: 69–78, 1998.
© 1998 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
69
Relationship between soil chemical factors and grassland diversity
F. Janssens
1
, A. Peeters
1
, J.R.B. Tallowin
2
, J.P. Bakker
3
, R.M. Bekker
3
, F. Fillat
4
and M.J.M.
Oomes
5
1
Laboratoire d’Ecologie des Prairies, UCL, Louvain-la-Neuve, BeIgium
* 2
Institute of Grassland and Environ-
mental Research, North Wyke, Great Britain,
3
Laboratory of Plant Ecology, University of Groningen, Haren, The
Netherlands,
4
CSIC-lnstituto Pirenaico de Ecologia, Jaca, Spain and
5
DLO-Research Instituto and Soil Fertility
(AB-DLO), Wageningen, The Netherlands
Received 19 July 1997. Accepted in revised form 7 April 1998
Key words: grassland, nitrogen, nutrient competition, phosphorus, plant diversity, potassium
Abstract
Many studies carried out during these last few years have focused on the factors influencing plant diversity in
species-rich grasslands. This is due to the fact that these ecosystems, among the most diversified in temperate
climates, are extremely threatened; in some areas, they have almost disappeared. The re-establishment of these
habitats implies to know the living conditions of the associations to be recreated. Very often, the typical species of
these communities have become so rarefied that the seed bank or the seed rain are not sufficient to recreate the plant
community. Most of the time, to achieve the restoration of these communities, they have to be totally recreated by
sowing. For the restoration or the maintenance of the community, the soil chemical characteristics have also to be
appropriate or if not modified. This research tends to establish a relation between some soil chemical factors and the
plant diversity of a great number of stations. This research has illuminated the relationship between soil extractable
phosphorus and potassium and plant diversity. Over 5 mg of phosphorusper 100 g of dry soil (acetate + EDTA
extraction), no station containing more than 20 species per 100 m
2
has been found. The highest number of species
is found below the optimum content of the soil for plant nutrition (5–8 mg P/100 g). Concerning the potassium, the
highest number of species is found at 20 mg/100, a value corresponcing to an optimum content of the soil for plant
nutrition. High potassium contents, in opposition to phosphorus contents, are thus compatible with high values
of diversity. Other factors (i.e. pH, organic matter, total nitrogen and calcium) do not show so clearly a relation
with plant diversity. Excess of N–NO
3
is known for its negative effect on the diversity of plant communities. In
these environments, apart from the atmospheric deposits which can be important in some areas, N–NO
3
is derived
mainly from the symbiotic fixation of atmospheric nitrogen by legumes as well as from the mineralization of the
organic matter of the soil. It is possible that, when in small quantities, the available soil phosphorus could be a
limiting factor of the N–NO
3
supply by these two sources. In this hypothesis, nitrogen would remain the main
element limitating plant diversity but its availability would be controlled by phosphorus.
Introduction
The grassland management intensification of these last
decades has considerably reduced the importance of
diversified swards in West-Central Europe (Baldock,
1990). The main factors affecting grassland diversity
are the cut regimes (especially silage involving early
*
FAX No: +32 10 472428. E-mail: Janssens@ecop.ucl.ac.be
cuts) and the increase of fertilizer use (especially ni-
trogen and phosphorus). The grassland flora, which is
the most species-rich ecosystem in the concerned area,
has become more and more simplified to eventually
be reduced, in some cases, to its lowest value: the
monospecific sward. The maintenance of some plant
communities in nature reserves has nowadays become
a common practice to slow down this evolution. This
solution is certainly very useful but it is insufficient.