Long Paper
© 2013 ACEEE
DOI: 01.IJRTET.9.1.
Int. J. on Recent Trends in Engineering and Technology, Vol. 9, No. 1, July 2013
513
Optimal Control of a Teleoperation System via LMI-
based Robust PID Controllers
A. Roushandel
1
, A. Alfi
2
, and A. Khosravi
3
1
Babol University of Technology/ Electrical and Computer Engineering Department, Babol, Iran
Email: a.roushandel@stu.nit.ac.ir
2
Shahrood University of Technology / Electrical and Robotic Engineering Department, Shahrood, Iran
Email: a_alfi@shahroodut.ac.ir
3
Babol University of Technology / Electrical and Computer Engineering Department, Babol, Iran
Email: akhosravi@nit.ac.ir
Abstract—Since the performance of the teleoperation systems
can be considerably degraded by time-delay of communication
channels and uncertainty in various parts of such systems,
the main objectives of the controller design in loads of different
structures of the bilateral teleoperation system are to preserve
stability and tracking performance of these systems in spite
of aforementioned sources of uncertainty. In this paper, a
new robust PID controller will be designed based on H
”
control
theory by using the Linear Matrix Inequality (LMI) approach.
Therefore, the problem of a Robust PID controller design can
be regarded as a special case of the output-feedback controller
via employing some sorts of changes in control and system
parameters. To show the effectiveness of the proposed
controller, the robust PID controller is compared with the
multiobjective H
2
/H
”
one. The main feature of the suggested
structure is its ability to control the teleoperation system via
using the simplest structure in which two signals will be
transmitted to control the teleoperation system. In addition,
use of PID controller has more practical applications in
industrial units, due to its simplicity in implementation and
capability to predict the time responses caused by changes in
control parameters.
Index Terms— Teleoperation systems, Robust LMI based PID
controller, Multiobjective H
2
/H
”
, Optimization.
I. INTRODUCTION
There has been a considerable growth in use of
teleoperation systems in different areas such as: telesurgery,
telemanipulation, space mission, nuclear power station, under
sea research, Etc. A typical bilateral teleoperation system
depicted in fig. 1 consists of five important parts: a human
operator, a master manipulator, communication channels, a
slave manipulator and remote environment. The master
manipulator is directly drawn by the human operator and its
position/velocity is transmitted to the slave site via
communication channel. The slave manipulator has to track
the position/velocity of master one and communicate
reactions of the remote (task) environment to the master
manipulator as the reflected force.
Although using the bilateral structure in teleoperation
systems increases ability of the human operator to control
the teleoperation system, if there was a long distance between
slave and master sites, performance and stability of the
overall system would be deeply affected. The performance
of a teleoperation system is addressed by an index called
transparency. Transparency is defined as a match between
forces that is exerted by the human operator and one which is
reflected from the task environment. In other words,
transparency is a capability of a teleoperation system to
represent unchanged dynamics of the remote environment to
the human operator [1]. Because of the existing uncertainties
in dynamics of the system and time-delay in communication
channels a compromise is required to be ensured between
transparency and stability [2]. Since an increase in stability
margins of the system leads to a decrease in transparency,
control of a bilateral teleoperation system requires a delicate
trade-off between two foregoing requirements namely
transparency and robust stability.
Until now several control schemes have been applied to
bilateral teleoperation systems so next some of these schemes
are considered briefly. H
”
control theory was used by Sano et
al. in 2000 [3]. They used four sensors in order to measure
positions and forces of master and slave systems. In 2002, a
new control method consisting of smith predictor and wave
variables was proposed by Ganjefar et al. [4] for optimizing
the performance of the teleportation system against the large
variable time-delay. An optimal H
2
procedure was proposed
for teleportation systems in 2004 by Boukhnifer and Ferreira
[5]. Sunny et al. [6] designed an adaptive position and force
stabilizing controller for bilateral teleportation system in 2005.
In the same year Ganjefar and Miri [7] used optimization
control method in teleportation systems. One year after that,
ShaSadeghi et al. [8] proposed a new control structure based
on adaptive inverse method while at this year Sirouspoor
and Shahdi [9] employed predictor controller for teleportation
systems. Tavakoli et al. suggested a modeling and stability
analysis for discrete teleoperation system in 2008 [10]. While
a sliding mode bilateral control was proposed by Moreau et
al. for Master-Slave pneumatic servo systems [11]. Novel
adaptive-based methods have been dedicated to various
structures of teleoperation systems [12-15] to reduce the
destructive effects of time delay and uncertainty on
performance of these systems. Additionally, different
disturbance based methods have been proposed for bilateral
teleoperation systems to preserve the stability and
performance [16-18].
50