ABSTRACT . This article provides a textual analysis of the pedagogical
discourse of history textbooks used in the education of Chilean students. In
particular, I focus on how the impact of Salvador Allende’s socialist
government (1970–1973) and the military coup that led to the Augusto
Pinochet’s dictatorship (1973–1990) are constructed by and displayed in these
texts. As a method of analysis, I apply the Systemic Functional Grammar
theory to history textbooks used in the sixth and eighth grades. Two of the
metafunctions proposed by Halliday – textual and interpersonal – are
particularly relevant when combined with an appraisal analysis fundamentally
based on the work of Martin because they provide a useful tool for interpreting
and explaining the text from an ideological standpoint. The analysis reveals
that the textbooks’ authors strive to sound objective, but instead offer a large
number of explicit and implicit judgements throughout the text. They purport
to present two antithetical political positions – that of Allende’s supporters and
that of the supporters of the military coup – however, the texts do not actually
offer two clear positions nor do they provide clear reasons for the events.
Instead, the authors obscure content through grammatical and lexical choices
– such as the use of ‘and’ as an expression of reason or cause; embedded
mental and verbal projection (sixth grade only); the absence of logico-semantic
relationship of elaboration; and modal adjuncts that signal judgement but not
explanation. Appraisal analysis in conjunction with a more discrete
grammatical analysis is useful for revealing the explicit, subjective choices
made in constructing these supposedly objective texts.
KEY WORDS : appraisal analysis, history textbooks, ideology, Systemic Functional
Grammar, textual analysis, textual and interpersonal metafunctions
By presenting an analysis of two Chilean history textbooks, I plan to show how
these texts, which are used by at least 85 percent of Chilean public school
ARTICLE 639
How contemporary history is presented
in Chilean middle school textbooks
TERESA OTEIZA
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA , DAVIS
Discourse & Society
Copyright © 2003
SAGE Publications
(London, Thousand Oaks,
CA and New Delhi)
www.sagepublications.com
Vol 14(5): 639–660
[0957-9265
(200309) 14:5;
639–660; 034845]