Journal of Child and Family Studies, VoL 1, No. 4, 1992,pp. 371-39i
Family Interaction and Child Psychopathology:
A Comparison of Two Observation Strategies
Mark R. Dadds, Ph.D., 1,3 and Matthew R. Sanders, Ph.D. 2
We examined two systems of assessing family interactions that are in common
usage: a home based observation of free parent-child interaction and a clinic
based observation of a structured mother-child problem solving discussion.
Participants were 18 depressed, 27 conduct disordered and 16 comparison
children and their mothers. Results indicated that: 1) these observations may
yield very different data about child, and to a lesser extent, parent behavior,
2) parental affect in the clinic was related to their level of aversive behaviour
in the home, 3) levels of both aversive and positive behavior for children and
their mothers were correlated within each setting, 4) accuracy of diagnostic
classifications made on the basis of the observational data were highest for
comparison and conduct disordered children, but lowest for depressed children
observed in the clinic, and 5) the inclusion of data on mothers" behavior
increased classification accuracy for conduct disordered children only.
KEY WORDS: family interaction; child; depression; conduct disorder; observation.
The last few decades have witnessed increasing interest in the role
of the family in the development, maintenance and treatment of child psy-
chopathology. The extent to which family structures and interactional
processes are causally related to specific forms of childhood psychopathology,
however, remains a contentious issue (Goodyer, 1990; Sines, 1987). A pre-
requisite for progress in this area is the existence of reliable and valid
1Co-Director for Interventions, Preventive Intervention Research Center for Child Health,
Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York.
2Co-Director, Behaviour Research and Therapy Centre, The University of Queensland,
Australia.
3Correspondence should be directed to Mark R Dadds, Preventive Intervention Research
Center, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, 1300 Morris Park Ave. NR 7South. Bronx. NY
10461.
371
1062-1024/92/1200-0371506.50/0 © 1992 Human Sciences Press, Inc.