Plant and Soil 121, 89-98 (1990).
© Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands. PLSO 8241
Root:shoot ratios of old and modern, tall and semi-dwarf wheats in a
mediterranean environment
K.H.M. SIDDIQUE, R.K. BELFORD and D. TENNANT
Division of Plant Industries, Western Australian Department of Agriculture, Baron-Hay Court, South
Perth, 6151, Western Australia
Received 11 May 1989. Revised August 1989
Key words: harvest index, old and modern wheats, root:shoot ratio, Rht genes, root dry matter, root
length, water use efficiency
Abstract
A field study tested the hypothesis that modern wheat varieties invest a lesser proportion of the total dry
matter (root plus shoot) in the root system compared to old varieties. The study was carried out on a duplex
soil (sand over clay) at Merredin, Western Australia in a Mediterranean type environment. We also
compared the root:shoot dry matter ratios of near-isogenic lines for Rht dwarfing genes.
Root:shoot ratios decreased with crop growth stage and were closely related to the developmental pattern
of a variety. All varieties appeared to accumulate more dry matter into shoots than roots after the terminal
spikelet stage. For the modern variety Kulin this occurred as early as 55 days after sowing (DAS), but did
not occur until 90 DAS in the old variety Purple Straw. For all varieties, root dry matter reached its
maximum at anthesis, while shoot dry matter continued to increase till maturity. At anthesis there were no
significant differences in shoot dry matter between varieties, but from Purple Straw to Kulin root dry matter
and thus root:shoot ratio decreased.
The tall and dwarf isogenic lines had similar developmental and root:shoot dry matter accumulation
patterns.
At anthesis, the old variety Purple Straw had significantly higher root dry matter and root length density
in the top 40-cm of the profile than modern variety Kulin. There were no varietal differences in rooting depth,
water extraction or water use. At maturity about 30% of the total dry matter was invested in the roots among
wheat varieties. Grain yield, harvest index (HI) and water use efficiency of grain (WUEgr) increased from
old to modern varieties.
The reduced investment of dry matter in the root system and thus the lower root:shoot ratio from early
in the growing season may partly explain the increased HI and WUEgr of modern compared to old varieties.
Introduction
Passioura (1983) provided substantial evidence
that roots are a major sink for assimilates, requir-
ing twice as much assimilate to produce unit dry
matter as do the shoots. He argued that the root
system of many crop plants may be unnecessarily
large; and if it was smaller, more assimilate could
be available for the shoot, to be used for higher
grain production, with an increase in water use
efficiency of grain.
89
Increase in harvest index (HI) appears to be a
consistent result of selection for higher grain yield
in wheat, with little change in the above ground
biomass (Austin eta!., 1980; Perry and D'Antuono,
1989). Recent studies in Western Australia (Kirby
et al., 1989; Loss et al., 1989; Siddique et al.,
1989a, b,c) have identified major changes in moving
from the old variety, Purple Straw (released 1860)
to the modern variety, Kulin (1986). Modern
varieties, adapted to the growing environment of
the Western Australian wheatbelt, differed from