Highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) often
leads to increases in a patient’s CD4+ T-cell count of
100–200 cells/μl or more, even though individual re-
sponses in cases of HIV-1 infection are quite variable
[1, 2, 3]. The CD4+ T-cell responses are generally relat-
ed to the degree of viral load suppression [1, 2]. How-
ever, a substantial proportion of patients undergoing
HAART have had persistently detectable viremia de-
spite their strict adherence to treatment [4, 5]. What
happens to those patients who remain highly viremic
while undergoing HAART is not fully understood,
though a sustained CD4+ T-cell response in patients
taking protease inhibitor (PI)-based regimens has been
reported [3, 4]. Diminished fitness of heavily mutated
viruses (that is, reduced ability of resistant virus to rep-
licate and deplete CD4+ T cells) could partly explain
these observations [6].
The durability of these immunologic responses that
occur despite failure of virological suppression is still
unknown, though a 24-month benefit has been reported
in patients continuing on PI-containing regimens [4]. We
report the results of a 36-month observational study per-
formed on 16 patients who had a sustained CD4+ T-cell
response despite high-level viremia and extensive drug
resistance while continuing combination antiretroviral
therapy.
The study population was selected from outpatients at
the Infectious Diseases Unit of the Pistoia Hospital, Pi-
stoia, Italy. The study design was single center, open-
label, and observational. On the basis of available re-
cords from a 3-year period, 16 (14 male and 2 female)
patients (10% of all HIV patients regularly followed) be-
tween the ages of 29 and 52 years (mean, 37 years) met
the study purpose. At baseline, the mean±SD viral load
was 4.36±1.05 log RNA copies/ml, and the mean CD4+
T-cell count was 400±353 cells/mm
3
. Seven patients
were in CDC stage A (A2=4; A3=3); two in stage B
(B1=1; B2=1); and seven in stage C (C2=1; C3=6) [7].
As starting treatment, 12 patients were given a PI plus
two nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NRTIs);
two patients were given two PIs plus a NRTI; one patient
received a non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor
plus two NRTIs; and one patient received two NRTIs.
Regimens were assigned on the basis of the level of vire-
mia, the degree of immunodeficiency, concurrent treat-
ments, and the presumptive patient’s commitment to
therapy and adherence. Study monitoring included coun-
selling; monthly assessment of adherence to treatment by
standardized questionnaire (graded as poor, good, or ex-
cellent); measurement of virus load (median, 14 times/
patient: range, 9–20); the CD4+ T-cell count (median
12 times/patient: range, 4–18; and genotyping resistance
testing (median, 4 times/patient: range, 2–7) as a guide
for switching treatment.
Virological failure was defined as a plasma HIV RNA
rebound after initial suppression to undetectable levels or
declines in HIV-RNA of <0.5 and <1.0 log, respectively,
by 4 and 8 weeks from the start of treatment [3]. The
plasma HIV-1 load was quantitated using the Roche
Amplicor method (Roche Laboratories, Switzerland).
The detection limit of the assay was 400 copies/ml.
For genotypic antiretroviral resistance testing, RNA
was extracted from plasma stored at –7°C using the
QIAmp Viral RNA kit (Qiagen, Germany). The HIV-1
pol regions coding for RT amino acids 1–230 and for the
whole protease were generated by reverse transcription-
nested polymerase chain reaction amplification and di-
rectly sequenced as described elsewhere [8]. Mutations
conferring resistance to the different reverse transcrip-
tase inhibitors and PIs were retrieved from available dat-
abases, and drug susceptibility was inferred with use of a
comprehensive set of rules [9].
D. Dionisio (
✉
) · A. Vivarelli · F. Esperti
C. Fabbri · M. Giorgi · B. Menichini
Infectious Diseases Unit, Pistoia Hospital,
Piazza Giovanni XXIII, 51100 Pistoia, Italy
e-mail: mpdioni@tin.it
Tel.: +39-0573-352324/352078, Fax: +39-0573-352076
M. Zazzi
Division of Microbiology, Department of Molecular Biology,
University of Siena, Siena, Italy
Eur J Clin Microbiol Infect Dis (2003) 22:69–71
DOI 10.1007/s10096-002-0845-7
BRIEF REPORT
D. Dionisio · A. Vivarelli · M. Zazzi · F. Esperti
C. Fabbri · M. Giorgi · B. Menichini
Long-term CD4+ T-Cell Response in HIV-1-Infected Patients Continuing
Combination Antiretroviral Therapy Despite High-Level Viremia
and Drug Resistance
Published online: 28 January 2003
© Springer-Verlag 2003