JCOT Vol 2 No 1 51 ©2011, DOA
*Assistant Professor, **Associate Professor,
†
Professor, Department of
Orthopedics, BRD Medical College, Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh.
Correspondence: Dr. Vikas Saxena, Assistant Professor, Department of
Orthopedics, BRD Medical College, Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh – 273001.
E-mail: doctorvikas2002@yahoo.co.in
flexion. Check X-ray showed satisfactory reduction (Figures 3
and 4). There was no evidence of post reduction sensorimotor
neural deficit in either hand. The patient was discharged and at
8 weeks, cast were removed and range of motion excercises started.
At 16 weeks, patient had pain-free wrists with a range of mo-
tion of 40° of dorsiflexion, 35° of palmar flexion, 40° of pronation
and 75° of supination. He could resume his duties after 16 weeks.
Six months post-reduction radiographs of both wrists showed
scaphoid fracture union with no evidence of avascular necrosis
(Figures 5 and 6). At 1-year follow-up, range of motion was
satisfactory with terminal limitation of movements in both
wrists.
DISCUSSION
Bilateral trans-scaphoid perilunate fracture dislocation is a rare
injury and only few cases have been reported in international
literature till date.
1
The prognosis of this kind of injury is un-
certain to predict.
2
Mechanism of injury is fall on the dorsum
of flexed wrist. Perilunate dislocation indicates extensive injury
to intercarpal ligaments, with only the lunate maintaining its
normal relationship with the radius. Extensive ligamentous dis-
ruption makes the reduction of this dislocation easier than the
reduction of lunate dislocation. Palmar trans-scaphoid perilu-
nate dislocations are extremely rare. Dorsal trans-scaphoid peri-
lunate dislocation like the fracture scaphoid bone alone is
diagnosed late and may be associated with other injuries of
upper extremity.
The key to diagnosis of these injuries of the wrist is the lat-
eral X-ray. Normally the axis of radius, the lunate, the capitate
and the third metacarpal should fall in a straight line with the
wrist in neutral position and the half moon-shaped profile of
lunate articulates with the cup of distal radius proximally and
with the rounded proximal capitate distally. On the AP view
the lunate has rectangular profile normally which when dislo-
cated becomes triangular because of its tilt.
Early reduction by closed manipulation is best. Reduction
of the dislocation is carried out by traction and flexion of the
distal portion with direct pressure over the displaced fragment.
A closed reduction usually can be carried out up to 3 weeks
after injury. The reduction tends to be unstable due to exten-
sive ligamentous damage and it may be impossible to obtain
and maintain accurate reduction of the scaphoid fragments
so open reduction and internal fixation is the preferred treat-
ment of choice for such displaced fractures. The risk of avascu-
lar necrosis as well as early and severe radiocarpal arthrosis
after trauma is likely to happen. The prognosis of this kind of
injury is uncertain to predict. In our case we could achieve
satisfactory reduction by closed means and patient was able
to perform early rehabilitation program about 8 weeks post
reduction. He recovered with a good range of movement in
both hands.
Recently the open reduction and internal fixation with early
and aggressive rehabilitation for trans-scaphoid injury was pro-
posed by several authors.
3–6
Early internal fixation of scaphoid
Bilateral symmetrical
trans-scaphoid perilunate
dislocation—a rare injury
Vikas Saxena, MS (Ortho)*
Pavan Pradhan, MS (Ortho)**
Ashok Yadav, MS (Ortho)*
Vineet Mehrotra, MS (Ortho)
†
INTRODUCTION
There have been only 6 reports of bilateral scaphoid fractures
without dislocation and 3 cases of bilateral scaphoid fractures
associated with perilunate dislocation in the international liter-
ature. We present a case of bilateral symmetrical scaphoid frac-
ture associated with perilunate dislocation. This patient
received immediate closed reduction and cast application with
early and aggressive rehabilitation program. After 4 months’
follow-up, there was no local site tenderness or deformity.
Minimal functional impairment was noted in both wrists at
1-year follow-up.
CASE REPORT
A 35-years-old policeman fell down from a height of around 20
feet bearing bodyweight over both pronated hand. Following in-
jury patient had bilateral wrist pain, swelling and deformity.
The patient was brought to BRD Medical College, Gorakhpur
2 hours after the injury. Roentgenograms revealed dorsal perilu-
nar dislocation with scaphoid fracture in both wrists as lunate
bone along with proximal fragment of scaphoid was in align-
ment with distal radius articular margin in lateral view while
perilunate carpal bones were dorsally displaced on both sides
and normal quadrilateral appearance of lunate turned into tri-
angular appearance in anteroposterior roentgenogram (Figures 1
and 2). There was no evidence of sensorimotor deficit in either
hand.
Both fractures were reduced by closed manipulation under
general anesthesia and below elbow cast applied in palmar